Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Project delivery method selector

Design-bid-build, construction manager at risk, design-build or integrated project delivery? Answer eleven questions about your project and owner, see how each answer moves each method, compare them side by side and download a decision memo.

  • Free
  • No signup
  • Runs in your browser
  • Shareable link

Your project

01Who is the owner, and what procurement rules apply?

Public owners can only use the methods their statutes or regulations authorize. Many states require low-bid design-bid-build unless a statute allows alternatives.

02How far along is the design when you would bring on the builder?

The earlier the builder joins, the more it can influence cost and constructability, and the less complete the design behind any price.

03How much schedule pressure is there?

Overlapping design and construction (fast-tracking) needs the builder on board before the design is done.

04When do you need a committed price?

Each method commits price at a different point and on a different basis.

05How much control does the owner want over design detail?

In design-bid-build and CMAR the designer works for the owner; in design-build the designer works for the design-builder.

06How complex or uncertain is the work?

Renovations, occupied buildings, heavy MEP and unknown site conditions reward builder input during design.

07How experienced and available is the owner’s team?

Collaborative methods need an owner who makes decisions quickly and participates in the project team.

08How important is a single point of responsibility for design and construction?

With separate contracts, design errors are between the owner and the designer, and the contractor may claim for them.

09Will the key parties share risk and reward under one agreement?

IPD typically uses a multi-party agreement with shared savings and overruns, and often limits claims among the parties.

10Is the lowest first cost through open price competition the priority?

Methods that select the builder on qualifications trade some price competition for early input.

11How likely is the scope to change during design?

After a price is committed, owner changes become change orders in every method.

For the memo (optional)

Best fitLive

Leading option

—

      The reasoning: points by answerLive

      Every answer adds or subtracts points for each method. Fit is each method’s points on a 0–100 scale between the lowest and highest total it could reach.

      Question and your answerDBBCMARDBIPD

      The four methods compared

      Design-bid-buildConstruction manager at risk (CMAR)Design-buildIntegrated project delivery (IPD)
      Contracts the owner signsTwo: designer and contractorTwo: designer and CM at riskOne: the design-builderOne multi-party agreement (owner, designer, builder), sometimes more parties
      Builder selected onLowest responsive, responsible bidQualifications, fee and general conditionsBest value or qualifications, sometimes priceQualifications and team fit
      Builder joinsAfter design is completeDuring design (often schematic)At the start, with the designerAt the start, as a core team member
      Price committedBid on complete documentsGMP during designLump sum or GMP, early or progressiveTarget cost, with shared savings and overruns
      Design responsibility to the ownerOwner’s designerOwner’s designerDesign-builderShared within the agreement
      Fast-track possibleRarelyYesYesYes
      Typical contract familiesAIA A101 / A201; ConsensusDocs 200AIA A133; ConsensusDocs 500AIA A141; DBIA 500 series; ConsensusDocs 410AIA C191; ConsensusDocs 300

      Contract families are named for orientation only; read the current editions before you use one. Progressive design-build and bridging sit between design-build and CM at risk.

      Sample answers: a private, complex project at schematic design with critical schedule pressure, a GMP in mind and an owner who wants to keep its own architect.

      Method

      How this is calculated

      The selector is a points model, not a black box. Each of the eleven answers adds or subtracts points for each method, based on how the methods allocate design responsibility, price timing, schedule overlap and risk. The weights are editorial judgment drawn from the sources below; they are shown in full in the points table so you can disagree with any of them.

      Points(method)  = Σ points of your answer to each question
      Fit(method)     = (points − lowest possible) ÷ (highest possible − lowest possible) × 100
      Not permitted   = a public owner limited to low-bid award: CMAR, DB and IPD are flagged
                        and sorted last until you confirm legal authority
      Close call      = top two within 10 fit points

      What moves the answer most

      Procurement authority comes first: a public owner limited to low-bid award can usually only use design-bid-build. After that, design completeness and schedule pressure separate design-bid-build from the rest, price timing separates CM at risk (a GMP during design) from design-build (an early price with design risk transferred) and IPD (a shared target cost), and owner staff and willingness to share risk decide whether IPD is realistic. Our guide to delivery methods walks through each one, and the glossary covers design-build, design-bid-build and preconstruction.

      How to choose a delivery method with this selector

      1. Answer the eleven questions. Pick the answer closest to your project for each question: who the owner is, how far the design is, schedule pressure, when you need a price, design control, complexity, owner staff, single responsibility, shared risk, price competition and scope stability.
      2. Read the ranking. Each method gets a fit score from 0 to 100. A method the owner may not be allowed to use is flagged and sorted last.
      3. Check the reasoning. Open the points table to see exactly which answer moved which method, and by how much. Change an answer and watch the ranking move.
      4. Compare the methods. Use the comparison table for how each method handles contracts, selection, price timing and design responsibility.
      5. Download the decision memo. Add the project and your name, then download the memo as a Word file or Markdown, or print it, for the owner, the board or the procurement file.

      Delivery method questions

      What are the main project delivery methods?

      Design-bid-build (the owner hires a designer, then bids the finished design to contractors), construction manager at risk (the owner hires a designer and, during design, a CM who later commits to a guaranteed maximum price), design-build (one contract for design and construction) and integrated project delivery (owner, designer and builder sign one agreement and share risk and reward). Variations include progressive design-build, bridging and multiple-prime contracting.

      Which delivery method is fastest?

      Methods that let construction start before design is finished: design-build, CM at risk and IPD. Design-bid-build runs design, bidding and construction in sequence, so it is usually the slowest from start to finish, though each phase is simple.

      Which method gives the lowest price?

      Design-bid-build gives the most direct price competition, because every bidder prices the same complete design. That does not always mean the lowest final cost: gaps in the design come back as change orders. CMAR and design-build trade some price competition for builder input during design.

      What is the difference between CM at risk and design-build?

      In CM at risk the owner holds two contracts, one with the architect and one with the CM, and the architect’s design is the owner’s responsibility. In design-build the owner holds one contract, and the design-builder is responsible for both the design and the construction.

      Can public owners use design-build or CM at risk?

      Only where a statute, charter or regulation authorizes it. Federal agencies can use two-phase design-build selection under FAR Subpart 36.3, and GSA uses construction manager as constructor under GSAM Subpart 536.71. States and local governments each have their own rules, and many limit alternative delivery to certain project types or sizes. Check your authority before you choose.

      What does it take to make IPD work?

      An experienced owner who participates in the team, a multi-party agreement with shared savings and overruns against a target cost, open-book accounting, and key parties brought on at the start. Without shared risk and reward it is collaboration under another method, not IPD.

      Is this tool’s recommendation authoritative?

      No. It is a transparent points model that organizes the main trade-offs. The points table shows every weight so you can disagree with it. Legal authority, lender and surety requirements and your own team’s experience can override any score.

      Sources

      Checked Nov 21, 2026. Public procurement authority varies by state, agency and project type. This tool does not determine what any owner is legally permitted to use.

      1. What Is Design-Build?, Design-Build Institute of America (checked Nov 21, 2026).Used for: design-build as a single contract for design and construction; progressive and two-step best value variations.
      2. FAR 36.104: Policy (construction and architect-engineer contracts), Acquisition.gov (checked Nov 21, 2026).Used for: federal use of design-bid-build or two-phase design-build selection.
      3. FAR 36.301: Use of two-phase design-build selection procedures, Acquisition.gov (checked Nov 21, 2026).Used for: when federal agencies use two-phase design-build: three or more offers expected, design work by offerors, defined requirements, time constraints and agency capacity.
      4. GSAM Subpart 536.71: Construction-Manager-as-Constructor Contracting, Acquisition.gov (checked Nov 21, 2026).Used for: federal CM-as-constructor: design-phase services at a firm fixed price with a construction option at a guaranteed maximum price.
      5. Integrated Project Delivery: A Guide (2007), AIA and AIA California Council (checked Nov 21, 2026).Used for: IPD principles: early involvement of key participants, shared risk and reward, multi-party agreements.

      When the spreadsheet version stops scaling

      Whatever the method, the contract and the money stay on one record.

      Delivery method decides who signs what. In os.construction the prime contract, its billing method and its schedule of values sit on the same project as the budget, commitments and change orders, so a GMP, a lump sum or a cost-plus job is tracked the same way.

      • Prime contracts with progress, GMP, cost-plus, unit price, T&M and milestone billing methods in Accounting (live).
      • GMP pay apps checked against the GMP before they can be certified (live).
      • Bidding with award review and buyout against a captured budget snapshot (live).

      Stop re-keying the numbers behind this math.

      Project Financials tracks job costs and billing. The Accounting module includes reviewed WIP snapshots, posting and close. Learn the apps and review historical source coverage before a cutover.

      Your role (optional)

      Email gets you product updates: what shipped and what's next. Start a free trial → Founding program →

      More free tools

      Pay app builderG702/G703-style pay app: SOV, stored materials, retainage reductions, change orders, error checks, roll-forward, print and Excel export.RetainageRetainage this period, a ledger over the life of the job with reductions and release, carrying cost, and state retainage rules.Over/under billingSingle-job over/under billing: cost-to-cost, units or physical %, pending COs, uninstalled materials and loss provision.Change order markupPrice a CO with burdened labor, tax, OH&P, tiered sub markup, insurance and bond, then track it in a CO log with exposure and aging.Estimate at completionFive EAC methods side by side (CPI, CPI×SPI, budget-rate, weighted, PM ETC) with TCPI, sensitivity and a monthly trend.Markup vs marginConvert markup to margin and back, price from a target margin, and see why 20% markup is not 20% margin.Labor burdenFully burdened hourly cost: payroll taxes with wage caps, workers' comp, GL, benefits, fringe and PTO.Bonding capacityUnderwriter-style adjusted working capital and net worth, single-job and aggregate ranges, backlog utilization and what-if levers.Bond premiumPerformance, payment and bid bond cost from your own surety’s tiered rate per $1,000: gross the premium into a bid and price change orders.Cash flow curveJob and portfolio cash curves: billing lag, retainage, pay-when-paid, peak financing need, interest cost and scenario compare.Punch list closeoutImport your punch log: open items by trade and age, a burn-down forecast with a confidence band, close rates each milestone needs, closeout checklist and Excel export.RFI response timeImport your RFI log: median and P90 turnaround in calendar or business days, on-time rate by party, ball-in-court aging, late RFIs with impact and an OAC report.Critical pathEnter activities with FS, SS, FF and SF logic and lags: forward and backward pass, total and free float, the critical path, a Gantt and a network diagram, with the math shown.Earned valuePV, EV and AC from budget and percent complete: CV, SV, CPI, SPI, three EAC formulas side by side, ETC, VAC and TCPI, with the math shown.General conditionsStaff, trailer, temp utilities and dumpsters by week, month or lump sum: total, weekly burn, share of contract and cost per extra week of delay.Bid bondPenal sum from a percentage, a fixed amount or the federal 20% rule, what you owe if you win and walk, and a withdrawal-risk check by stage, mistake type and state.NTP generatorFull or limited NTP letter: commencement, contract time in calendar or working days (federal holidays skipped), completion dates, early-work caps and an acknowledgment. Word, text or print.Back chargeBurdened labor, material, equipment and other trades, markup only where the subcontract allows it, the notice and cure timeline, and how much comes off the next payment.ContingencyOwner and contractor contingency against percent complete: burn index, straight-line chart, projection to completion, pending exposure and an Excel tracker with live formulas.Closeout packagePick the building’s systems and contract terms and get its closeout package: TCO and CO readiness, Cx, as-builts, O&M, warranties and final payment, with due dates and an Excel checklist.WIP schedule workbenchMulti-job WIP schedule: over/under billing, fade vs prior, loss provisions, pending COs and surety ratios. Printable report and Excel with formulas.Bring your own jobFive numbers from one of your jobs, or your whole pasted WIP schedule, rendered on the os.construction dashboard: over/under billing, margin, fade risk. Runs in your browser.Migration plannerPhased plan to move onto one system: cutover off year-end and peak season, risks and exports.Stack assessment10 questions, 3 minutes. Score your systems across five dimensions and get concrete next steps.

      Ask the OS

      Reading this page

      Ask anything about this page. Answers use what you're reading as context.

      Suggested

        AI · may be imperfect · sample data where shown

        Open file