Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Design-build vs design-bid-build vs CM at risk vs IPD

A project delivery method decides who signs with whom, when the price gets fixed and who answers when the drawings and the field disagree. Here are the four common methods drawn as contract diagrams, compared side by side, with the payment terms that sit on top of them.

Visual guide18 min read

Two separate choices

Delivery method first, payment basis second

People often say “a design-build job” and “a cost-plus job” as if they were the same kind of label. They aren’t. A project delivery method sets the relationships: who the owner contracts with for design, who for construction, and when each party joins the project. A payment basis sets how the builder is paid: a fixed lump sum, unit prices, a guaranteed maximum price, cost-plus or time and materials.

The two choices interact, and some pairings are far more common than others, but they are separate decisions. A design-build contract can be lump sum or GMP. A CM at risk contract is usually cost plus a fee with a GMP. Getting the distinction straight makes everything else on this page easier to follow.

Watch the explainer · 1:57

Design-build vs design-bid-build vs CM at risk

  1. 0:00Three ways to buy a building
  2. 0:12Design-bid-build
  3. 0:31Design-build
  4. 0:49CM at risk and the GMP
  5. 1:14Side by side
  6. 1:36One project record
Read the transcript

Design-bid-build, design-build and construction manager at risk are three ways an owner can buy a building. The difference comes down to how many contracts the owner signs, and when the builder gets involved.

Design-bid-build is the traditional sequence. The owner hires an architect, the design is finished, and then contractors bid on it. The low responsive bidder usually wins. The owner holds two separate contracts, so when the drawings have gaps, the owner sits between the designer and the builder.

In design-build, the owner signs one contract with one team that both designs and builds. Design and construction can overlap, which can shorten the schedule, and one party answers for both. The trade-off is less owner control over design details once the criteria are set.

Construction manager at risk keeps the architect on its own contract, but hires the builder early, during design, to advise on cost, schedule and constructability. When the design is far enough along, the construction manager commits to a guaranteed maximum price, or GMP, and then holds the trade contracts. Costs above the GMP are generally the construction manager's risk, unless the scope changes.

So, design-bid-build: two contracts, and a builder picked on price after design. Design-build: one contract for both. CM at risk: two contracts, with the builder in early and a price ceiling set before construction. The right one depends on how much speed, design control and price certainty the owner needs.

Whatever the method, the builder tracks the same things. In os.construction, the prime contract, budget, commitments, change orders and payment applications sit on one project record, so a GMP job and a lump-sum job are run from the same data.

Scroll through the four methods below. Solid lines are contracts; dashed lines are working relationships with no contract between the parties.

The four delivery methods as contract diagrams

  1. 01 · Design-bid-build

    Design it, bid it, build it

    The owner hires an architect, who completes the drawings and specifications. The owner then puts that design out to bid and signs a separate construction contract, often with the lowest responsive, responsible bidder on public work. The architect and the contractor coordinate during construction but have no contract with each other.

    The upside is a price on a finished design and full owner control of that design. The cost is time, because the phases run in sequence, and a seam between designer and builder where gaps in the drawings turn into change orders.

  2. 02 · Design-build

    One contract for design and construction

    In design-build the owner signs one contract with a design-builder, which holds the architect and engineers as consultants (or employs them) along with the trade subs. Design can overlap construction, so early work such as sitework and foundations can start before the last drawings are done.

    The owner gets one point of responsibility. In exchange it defines what it needs in performance criteria rather than controlling every design choice.

  3. 03 · CM at risk

    Builder at the design table, then a GMP

    In construction manager at risk the owner keeps its own architect but hires the CM during design for estimating, constructability reviews and scheduling. Once the design is far enough along, the CM commits to a guaranteed maximum price, holds the trade subcontracts and takes on the risk of building within it.

    Not to be confused with agency CM, where the construction manager advises the owner for a fee and doesn’t hold the construction risk.

  4. 04 · Integrated project delivery

    One agreement, shared outcome

    In IPD the owner, architect, builder and often key trades sign a single multi-party agreement. They set a target cost together, and part of each party’s profit rides on how the whole project does. Many IPD agreements also limit claims between the parties.

    Published forms include the AIA’s C191 multi-party agreement and the ConsensusDocs 300 tri-party agreement.

  5. 05 · The second choice

    Payment basis sits on top

    Each method can carry more than one way of paying the builder. Design-bid-build is usually lump sum or unit price. CM at risk is usually cost plus a fee with a GMP. Design-build runs both ways. IPD tends toward cost reimbursement against a target cost.

    Time and materials shows up under every method, mostly to price changes. More on each basis below.

Method by method

What each method means for the builder

01 Design-bid-build (DBB)

Design-bid-build is the traditional method and still the default for a lot of public work, because competitive sealed bidding on a complete design is easy to audit. For the general contractor, the job is won on price. Estimating time goes into a full takeoff, sub bids and bid leveling in the days before bid day, and the margin is set the moment the bid is submitted. On public work the bid usually has to come with a bid bond; see our guide to construction bonds.

Because the owner provides the design, the owner generally carries the risk that the design is adequate. In the US this is often called the Spearin doctrine, after a 1918 Supreme Court case. Contractors still have duties to review the documents and raise what they find, and contract language can shift the balance. In practice, the friction on DBB jobs gathers around RFIs, design clarifications and the change orders that follow them.

02 Design-build (DB)

In design-build the design-builder answers for the design and for the work. When a detail doesn’t work in the field, there is no one else to send the RFI to, so design-related changes become the design-builder’s own cost unless the owner changed its requirements. That accountability is the main thing owners buy. For how the money moves on a design-build job and what software has to carry, see design-build software.

There are two broad flavors. In lump-sum design-build, the owner issues criteria documents (sometimes a partly developed “bridging” design) and design-builders compete on price and approach. In progressive design-build, promoted by the Design-Build Institute of America (DBIA), the owner picks a team mainly on qualifications, develops the design with it, and agrees a price, often a GMP, at a defined point, with an option to stop if the price doesn’t work.

03 Construction manager at risk (CMAR)

CM at risk, also called CM/GC, keeps the owner’s direct relationship with the architect while bringing the builder in early. Preconstruction services, usually paid as a separate fee, include estimates at each design milestone, value engineering, constructability reviews and early schedule work. When the GMP is set, the estimate becomes a commitment, so the honesty of those preconstruction numbers matters.

A GMP is typically built from the cost of the work, the CM’s fee, general conditions and a CM contingency, with allowances for scope not yet defined. The job then runs open book: the owner can audit costs, contingency use and buyout. The CM usually bids the trade packages and awards subcontracts, often with the owner involved in the selection.

For the GMP flow from buyout to settlement, and what os.construction does and doesn’t do for it today, see CM at risk software.

04 Integrated project delivery (IPD)

IPD goes further than the others. Key parties are bound by one agreement, decisions are made jointly, and compensation is typically split into actual cost, which is reimbursed, and profit, which is partly or fully at risk against shared goals such as the target cost, schedule and quality. Lean construction practices such as target value design and pull planning are common on IPD jobs.

The model asks a lot of the owner: senior people at the table, quick decisions and a team chosen for trust as much as price. It tends to be used on complex projects where the owner expects scope and conditions to change and wants everyone solving the problem rather than pricing it. Some owners use the collaborative practices without the full multi-party contract, sometimes called “IPD-ish” or “IPD-lite”.

05 Multi-prime contracting

In multi-prime delivery the owner hires a designer, then splits construction into several prime contracts, typically general construction, mechanical, electrical and plumbing, each bid and signed separately. There is no general contractor holding the whole job. Someone still has to schedule the site, sort out which prime owns a scope gap and keep one trade from delaying another, and in multi-prime that is the owner, either with its own staff or through an agency construction manager (CM as adviser) it hires for the purpose.

Owners choose it to save a layer of markup and to keep each trade contract visible. The cost is coordination risk: when the electrical prime is late and the drywall prime claims delay, the owner sits in the middle. Some jurisdictions require it on public work. New York’s Wicks Law (General Municipal Law §101) requires separate specifications and prime contracts for plumbing, HVAC and electrical work on many public projects above set dollar thresholds, with exceptions such as project labor agreements. For a builder bidding one prime, read the coordination and scheduling clauses as closely as the scope: they decide who pays when another prime holds you up.

Design-build variants you will see in RFQs

  • Lump-sum (or fixed-price) design-build. Teams compete on a price and a technical proposal against the owner’s criteria. The price is fixed early, on little design, so proposals carry design contingency. Federal agencies commonly run it as the two-phase selection in FAR 36.3: qualifications first, then price and technical proposals from a short list.
  • Bridging design-build. The owner’s own architect takes the design part of the way, often to schematic design or a little beyond (the bridging documents), before design-builders price and finish it. More owner control, less design-builder freedom.
  • Progressive design-build. Select on qualifications, develop the design together in a paid first phase, then agree a GMP or lump sum. The owner keeps an off-ramp: if the number doesn’t work, it can take the design and procure construction another way. DBIA publishes progressive agreements (DBIA 544, and 545 for water and wastewater).
  • Design-build-operate (DBO) and DBFOM. The design-builder also runs and maintains the facility for a set period; add financing and it becomes a public-private partnership. Common for water, wastewater and transit.
  • Design-assist. Not a delivery method on its own: under DBB or CMAR, key trades (often mechanical, electrical, curtain wall) are hired during design to help the architect detail their systems. The architect stays designer of record.
Timeline

How the timeline changes, and when price gets fixed

The clearest way to see the trade-off is on one time axis. Design-bid-build waits for a finished design, so the price is firm but construction starts late. Every other method lets construction start earlier, and pays for it by committing to a price on a less complete design: at award in lump-sum design-build, at the GMP in CM at risk and progressive design-build, or as a shared target cost at the very start of IPD.

When design, procurement and construction happen under each delivery methodSix rows on one relative time axis. Design-bid-build runs design, then bidding, then construction, with the price fixed at bid. Multi-prime is similar but bids several prime contracts, sometimes in more than one round. CM at risk overlaps preconstruction with design and fixes a GMP before design ends so early construction can start. Lump-sum design-build fixes the price at award, before most design, and overlaps design with construction. Progressive design-build selects the team first and sets a price partway through design. IPD sets a target cost at the start and overlaps everything. Illustrative, not to scale.RELATIVE TIMING · ILLUSTRATIVEstartfinish →Design-bid-buildDBBbidMulti-primeseveral primesbidsCM at riskCMARGMPDesign-buildlump sumawardProgressive DBtwo phasesGMPIPDone agreementtargetdesignbid / select / preconconstructionprice committed
The more design and construction overlap, the earlier the price has to be committed on a less complete design. Bar lengths are illustrative, not durations.

Two practical consequences for the builder. First, the earlier the price, the more design contingency it has to carry, and the more the job depends on clean allowances and a clear owner program. Second, overlapping means early packages (sitework, foundations, steel, long-lead equipment) are bought before the drawings are done, so buyout runs in waves and the cost report has to track committed versus still-to-buy scope package by package.

Risk and responsibility

Who answers when something goes wrong

Most of the difference between methods shows up when something breaks. The grid below shows where the main risks usually land under the common standard forms. It is a default, not a rule: contract language moves risk in every method, and some risks stay with the owner almost everywhere, such as information it supplies, differing site conditions and changes it asks for.

Who usually carries the main risks under each delivery methodA grid of five risks against five methods. Design errors: owner under design-bid-build, multi-prime and CM at risk; design-builder under design-build; shared under IPD. Gaps between trade scopes: the general contractor, the owner under multi-prime, the CM, the design-builder, or the IPD team. Cost overrun on the agreed scope: the general contractor, each prime on its own contract, the CM above the GMP, the design-builder, or the shared risk pool under IPD. Daily coordination: the GC, the owner or its CM adviser under multi-prime, the CM, the design-builder or the IPD team. Owner contracts: two, one plus one per prime, two, one, or one shared agreement. Blue is owner, orange is builder side, green is shared.DBBMulti-primeCMARDBIPDDesign errorsbad drawingsOwnerOwnerOwnerD-BSharedTrade gapsunpriced scopeGCOwnerCMD-BTeamOverruncost over priceGCPrimesCMD-BPoolCoordinationrunning the siteGCOwnerCMD-BTeamOwner contractsdesign + build21 + N211 (all)ownerbuilder sideshared
Where risk lands by default. Owner-supplied information, differing site conditions and owner changes usually stay with the owner under every method; the contract can move any of these.
  • Design errors. When the owner supplies the design (DBB, multi-prime, CM at risk), US courts generally hold that the owner impliedly warrants it to the builder: the Spearin doctrine, from United States v. Spearin (1918). The owner then looks to its architect’s standard of care. In design-build the design-builder produces the drawings, so that warranty largely flips. CM at risk sits in between in practice: a CM that reviewed the design for constructability may face arguments that it should have caught a problem, depending on its contract.
  • Gaps between trades. A general contractor, CM or design-builder buying all the trades owns any scope that falls between subcontracts. In multi-prime nobody does except the owner, which is the main reason multi-prime jobs need strong coordination.
  • Overrun on the agreed scope. Above a lump sum or GMP, generally the builder’s, unless the scope changed through a change order. Under IPD, cost is usually reimbursed and an overrun eats into the shared profit pool first.
Contract documents

The standard contract forms for each method

Most US private work, and a lot of public work, starts from one of three families of standard forms: AIA Contract Documents, ConsensusDocs (endorsed by a coalition that includes AGC) and, for design-build, the DBIA forms. Public owners often use their own. The table lists the main owner-level agreements; each family also has subcontract, consultant and general-conditions documents that go with them.

Main owner agreements by method · check current editions
MethodAIAConsensusDocsDBIA / other
Design-bid-buildA101 (stipulated sum) or A102 (cost plus fee, with or without a GMP), with A201 general conditions; B101 owner-architect200 owner-constructor (lump sum); 240 owner-design professionalEJCDC forms are common on engineered public works
Design-buildA141 owner/design-builder; A142 design-builder/contractor; B143 design-builder/architect410 (cost of the work plus fee with a GMP); 415 (lump sum); 400 preliminary agreementDBIA 520 preliminary agreement, 525 and 530 owner/design-builder agreements, 535 general conditions
Progressive design-buildUsually adapted from the A141 family400 preliminary agreement, then 410 with a GMP amendmentDBIA 544; 545 for water and wastewater
CM at riskA133 (CM as constructor, GMP) or A134 (no GMP), with A201; B133 owner-architect500 owner-CM at risk with GMPAgency forms under state CMAR statutes
IPDC191 single multi-party agreement300 tri-party collaborative agreementCustom IPD agreements are common
Multi-prime with CM adviserA132 owner-contractor, C132 owner-CM adviser, B132 owner-architectProgram and construction management formsAgency forms; state separate-prime statutes

Editions change: AIA’s design-build family dates from 2014 and its CM family from 2019, and ConsensusDocs published updated 410 and 415 agreements in December 2024. Always read the edition you are actually signing.

Side by side

The comparison matrix

General tendencies, not guarantees. A well-written DBB contract can share risk better than a poorly written IPD agreement. Dots run from none to high.

Delivery methods compared · general tendencies
CriterionDesign-bid-buildDesign-buildCM at riskIPDMulti-prime
Owner contracts for design and constructionHow many agreements the owner holdsTwo: designer and contractorOne: the design-builderTwo: designer and CMOne multi-party agreementOne with the designer, one per prime trade
When the price is setThe point the owner gets a committed numberAt bid, on a complete designAt award (lump sum) or at a later point (progressive)GMP once the design is developed enoughTarget cost set by the team, earlyAt bid, package by package
Speed potentialHow much design and construction can overlapLow: phases run in sequenceHigh: design and build overlapMedium to high: early packages possibleHigh: whole team from day oneLow to medium: packages can be bid in waves
Owner control of design detailSay over each design decisionHigh: designer works for the ownerLower: owner sets criteria, builder designsHigh: designer works for the ownerShared: decisions made jointlyHigh: designer works for the owner
Builder input during designConstructability, cost and schedule adviceNone before bidBuilt inPaid preconstruction servicesBuilt in, trades includedNone before bid, unless a CM adviser is hired
Single point of responsibilityOne party answers for design and constructionNo: gaps fall between contractsYesNo, but the CM shares the design tableShared by the signatoriesNo: the owner coordinates the primes
Owner involvement neededStaff time and decision speedModerateLower day to day, heavy up frontModerate to highHigh and continuousHigh: owner or its CM coordinates
Typical payment basisWhat usually sits on top (see below)Lump sum or unit priceLump sum or GMPCost of work plus fee, with a GMPCost reimbursable, target cost, fee at riskLump sum per prime contract
Often a fit whenA starting point, not a ruleScope is well defined and rules require low-bid awardSpeed and one accountable party matter mostOwner wants design control plus early cost and schedule inputComplex, high-uncertainty work with a committed, experienced teamLaw requires separate primes, or the owner has strong in-house construction management
The second layer

Lump sum, GMP, cost-plus and T&M

The payment basis decides who absorbs a cost overrun on the agreed scope. Changes in scope are a separate matter: under every basis, an owner-directed change should come through a change order. The spectrum below shows where the overrun risk tends to sit.

Who carries cost-overrun risk under each payment basisA spectrum from contractor carries the overrun on the left to owner carries the overrun on the right. Lump sum sits far left, unit price left of center, GMP in the middle, cost-plus right of center and time and materials far right. A not-to-exceed or ceiling pulls cost-plus and T&M back toward the middle.Contractor riskOwner riskLump sumUnit priceGMPCost-plusT&Ma ceiling or NTE pulls risk back
Illustrative placement. The contract’s definitions of cost, fee, contingency and change decide the real split.
Lump sum · stipulated sum

One price for the defined scope

The contractor agrees to deliver the scope in the contract documents for a fixed price. If its costs come in higher, that is its loss; if lower, its gain. Owners get price certainty and less paperwork; contractors carry estimating risk. Billing is progress against a schedule of values. See the lump sum glossary entry.

Unit price

Fixed rates, measured quantities

Common in heavy civil and site work where quantities can’t be known in advance. The contractor carries the risk on the rate per unit; the owner carries the risk on how many units it takes. Large quantity swings often trigger repricing clauses. See unit price contract.

GMP · cost plus fee, capped

Actual cost plus a fee, up to a ceiling

The owner reimburses the cost of the work as the contract defines it, plus a fee, up to the guaranteed maximum. Overruns above the GMP are generally the contractor’s, unless the scope changes. Savings below it may return to the owner or be shared. Every pay app has to show its costs. See GMP and our concept page on owner billing on GMP jobs.

Cost-plus

Cost reimbursed, fee on top, no cap

The owner pays actual reimbursable costs plus a fee that is either fixed or a percentage of cost. It suits work that can’t be defined well enough to price, with the owner carrying most of the cost risk. A percentage fee rewards higher cost, which is why US federal contracting bars the cost-plus-a-percentage-of-cost system outright (FAR 16.102(c)). See cost-plus contract.

Time and materials

Hourly rates plus materials

Labor is billed at agreed hourly rates that already include overhead and profit, and materials at cost, sometimes with a markup. It is common for small, undefined or emergency work and for pricing changes, usually with a not-to-exceed amount. In US federal contracting it is allowed only when the work can’t be estimated with reasonable confidence, and needs a ceiling price (FAR 16.601). See time and materials contract.

In os.construction, T&M work is recorded on T&M tickets and priced through change events and change orders; the T&M explainer follows one ticket to a priced change. Progress billing runs through payment applications against the schedule of values.

When to use each

A quick guide to choosing

  • Choose design-bid-build when the scope can be fully designed before bidding, a firm price on that design matters most, and procurement rules call for low-bid award. Accept a longer schedule and change orders from design gaps.
  • Choose multi-prime when the law requires separate trade contracts, or when the owner has strong construction management staff (or will hire an agency CM) and wants direct contracts with major trades.
  • Choose CM at risk when the owner wants to keep its own architect and control design, but needs builder input on cost and schedule during design and the option to start early packages before the drawings are done.
  • Choose design-build when speed and one accountable party matter most and the owner can state what it needs as performance requirements. Choose progressive design-build when the scope is still forming and the owner wants to shape the design with the team before locking a price.
  • Choose IPD for complex, high-uncertainty work where the owner can commit senior people to joint decisions and the team has worked collaboratively before.

Then pick the payment basis that suits how well the scope is defined. A firm lump sum needs a complete scope; a GMP or cost-plus fits scope that is still moving; time and materials fits small or undefined work.

Decision helper

Which method fits your priorities?

Tick what matters most on the project. Each priority leans toward some methods, using the tendencies in the matrix above. It is a conversation starter for the owner’s team, not a recommendation, and procurement law may rule some methods out. For eleven questions with the points behind every answer and a decision memo to download, use the delivery method selector.

Project priorities

Pick one or more priorities to rank the methods.

FAQ

Common questions

What is the difference between design-build and design-bid-build?

In design-bid-build the owner hires a designer first, completes the design, then bids it to contractors and signs a separate construction contract. In design-build the owner signs one contract with a design-builder who is responsible for both design and construction, so the two can overlap. Design-bid-build gives the owner more control over the design and a price on a finished design; design-build usually trades some of that control for speed and a single point of responsibility.

Is CM at risk the same as design-build?

No. Under construction manager at risk the owner still holds a separate contract with the architect, and hires the CM early to give preconstruction advice before committing to a guaranteed maximum price (GMP). Under design-build, the designer works for the design-builder, not the owner.

What is a GMP contract?

A guaranteed maximum price contract pays the contractor its actual cost of the work plus a fee, up to a ceiling. Costs above the GMP are generally the contractor’s responsibility, unless the scope changes through a change order. How savings below the GMP are handled depends on the contract; they may go back to the owner or be shared.

What is the difference between cost-plus and time and materials?

A cost-plus contract reimburses the contractor’s actual costs, as the contract defines them, plus a fee that is fixed or a percentage. A time and materials contract pays agreed hourly labor rates that already include overhead and profit, plus materials, often with a not-to-exceed amount. T&M is common for small or undefined work and for pricing changes.

Which project delivery method is fastest?

Methods that let design and construction overlap, such as design-build, CM at risk with early packages, and IPD, can shorten the overall schedule compared with design-bid-build, where each phase waits for the one before. Actual speed depends on the owner’s decisions, permitting, the team and the contract.

What is multi-prime contracting?

In multi-prime delivery the owner signs separate prime contracts with several trade contractors, for example general construction, mechanical, electrical and plumbing, instead of one general contract. Nobody below the owner holds the whole job, so the owner or a construction manager acting as its adviser coordinates the primes. Some public owners use it by choice; New York’s Wicks Law requires separate prime contracts for certain trades on many public projects.

What is progressive design-build?

Progressive design-build is design-build in two steps. The owner selects the design-builder mainly on qualifications, pays it to develop the design and preconstruction work with the owner, and then agrees a price, usually a GMP or lump sum, once the design is far enough along. If the price doesn’t work, the owner can typically take the design and procure construction another way. DBIA publishes standard progressive design-build agreements.

Which contract documents are used for design-build?

The common US standard forms are the AIA design-build family (A141 between owner and design-builder, with A142 and B143 for the design-builder’s contractor and architect), ConsensusDocs 410 (cost of the work plus a fee with a GMP) and 415 (lump sum), and the DBIA agreements, including progressive design-build forms. Public owners often use their own forms under a design-build statute.

What is a design-build-operate contract?

Design-build-operate (DBO) adds operation and maintenance to the design-build contract: the same party designs, builds and then runs the facility for a set period, often years, under performance standards. It is common for water and wastewater plants and transit. Adding financing makes it design-build-finance-operate-maintain (DBFOM), the usual public-private partnership model.

Can public owners use design-build or CM at risk?

Often, but it depends on the law that governs the owner. Many public owners are required to use competitive low-bid procurement unless a statute authorizes another method, and the authority, project size limits and selection rules vary by state, agency and country. Check the owner’s procurement rules before planning around a method.

Keep going

Sources and further reading

General information only, not legal, procurement or financial advice. Rules differ by jurisdiction, owner and contract; talk to a construction attorney about a specific agreement.

Want this on live job data?

os.construction runs the contract side of any delivery method: budgets, commitments, change orders and pay apps on one record.

Your role (optional)

14-day free trial. Pricing for paid plans isn't set yet. Talk to us. Already have an account? Sign in →

General information, not legal or procurement advice. Delivery methods and contract forms vary by owner, jurisdiction and agreement; the contract you sign and the law that governs it decide how risk and payment actually work.

Ask the OS

Reading this page

Ask anything about this page. Answers use what you're reading as context.

Suggested

    AI · may be imperfect · sample data where shown

    Open file