Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

General contractor vs construction manager: roles, risk and how each gets paid

A general contractor holds the construction contract and the trade subcontracts, usually after design is done. A construction manager joins during design, either as the owner's adviser or at risk under a guaranteed maximum price. Here is how the roles differ, when each fits, a worked example and the mistakes owners and builders make.

Charley Forey5 min readContractsPreconstructionProject management
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. How the general contractor role works
  3. How the construction manager role works
  4. A worked example
  5. When each one fits
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Related reading
  8. FAQ

A general contractor (GC) holds the construction contract with the owner and the trade subcontracts, and is usually hired after design to build the finished documents for a price. A construction manager (CM) joins during design to provide preconstruction services, and then either builds the project under a guaranteed maximum price as a CM at risk, or stays the owner’s adviser as a CM agent while the owner holds the trade contracts. The real difference is when the builder joins, who holds the trade contracts and who carries the cost risk.

The labels are about contract position, not company type. The same firm can be a GC on a hard-bid school, a CM at risk on a hospital and a design-builder on a warehouse in the same year.

Side by side

General contractor CM at risk CM agent (adviser)
When it joins After design, on hard-bid work; earlier if negotiated During design During design, sometimes earlier
Usually selected on Price, sometimes best value Qualifications, plus fees and general conditions Qualifications and fee
Preconstruction services Limited on hard-bid work Yes: estimates, constructability, scheduling, VE Yes
Holds trade contracts Yes Yes No, the owner does
Typical price basis Lump sum, sometimes cost-plus or GMP Cost plus a fee up to a GMP Fee for services
Cost risk after the price is set Contractor CM, above the GMP Owner
Books open to the owner Usually not on lump sum Yes n/a; owner sees trade costs directly
Savings Contractor keeps them on lump sum Owner, or shared per contract Owner
Common AIA family A101 or A102 with A201 A133 with A201 C132
When the builder joins under each approachA design and construction timeline: schematic design, design development, construction documents, bid and construction. A construction manager joins at schematic design, provides preconstruction services through design, and either sets a GMP and builds as CM at risk or keeps advising as CM agent. A general contractor on a hard-bid project joins at bidding, after construction documents.SCHEMATICDESIGN DEV.CONST. DOCSBIDCONSTRUCTIONCM: PRECONSTRUCTION SERVICESCM AT RISK BUILDS TO GMPGC BIDS AND BUILDSHARD BID: NO BUILDER YETTHE EARLIER THE BUILDER JOINS, THE MORE IT CAN SHAPE COST
Timing is the main difference. Simplified; a GMP is often set before construction documents are finished.

How the general contractor role works

On traditional design-bid-build work, the owner’s architect finishes the drawings, the owner bids them, and the general contractor with the best qualifying price signs a construction contract. The GC buys out the trades, runs the site, schedule, safety and quality, manages RFIs, submittals and changes, bills monthly against a schedule of values and closes the job out.

On a lump sum, the GC’s costs are its own business. If buyout comes in under the estimate, the GC keeps the difference; if it overruns, the GC absorbs it. The owner’s protection is competition at bid time and the change order process afterward. Some GCs also work on negotiated contracts with preconstruction input, which blurs the line with CM at risk.

How the construction manager role works

A CM at risk is hired during design, often on qualifications plus a proposed preconstruction fee, general conditions and a construction fee percentage. Through preconstruction it estimates at each design milestone, reviews constructability, proposes value engineering and plans long-lead procurement. When the documents can support it, the CM proposes a GMP with its assumptions, allowances and contingency. Once accepted, it bids and awards trade packages, builds the job and bills actual cost plus fee, open-book, up to the GMP.

A CM agent, sometimes called CM as adviser, provides many of the same services but never takes the construction contract. The owner signs the trade contracts directly, and the CM manages them on the owner’s behalf for a fee. The owner gets expertise without a markup on the trades, and keeps the cost risk.

A worked example

Illustrative: an owner plans a $24,000,000 medical office building.

As a hard bid, the architect finishes construction documents, five GCs bid, and the low qualified bid of $23,400,000 wins. The owner learns the real price only after design is done. A redesign at that point costs time and fees.

With a CM at risk, the owner hires a CM at schematic design for a preconstruction fee. At design development the CM’s estimate is $26,100,000. The team adjusts the facade and mechanical system before the design is finished, and the CM later proposes a GMP of $24,300,000 including a contractor contingency. Trade buyout lands $500,000 under the estimate, and if that saving holds to final cost, a shared savings clause gives most of it back to the owner.

Neither route is cheaper by definition. The hard bid tests price hard but late. The CM route spends money earlier to get cost and constructability input while the design can still change.

The risk picture differs too. After award, the hard-bid GC carries the cost of its own mistakes and keeps its savings, and the owner sees only the contract price and change orders. The CM at risk carries overruns above the GMP, but the owner sees every cost, audits the books and shares in savings.

When each one fits

A general contractor on a hard bid fits projects with complete design, a clear scope, a fixed budget and an owner, often public, that needs price competition. It also fits owners who don’t want to be involved in day-to-day cost decisions.

A CM at risk fits complex or fast-track projects, renovations of occupied buildings and owners who want builder input during design and open books during construction.

A CM agent fits owners with the staff and appetite to hold trade contracts themselves, and those who want an independent adviser without a builder’s financial interest in the price.

Common mistakes

  • Using “GC” and “CM” as interchangeable job titles in RFPs, which leaves the risk allocation unclear.
  • Setting the GMP too early, on drawings with too many assumptions and exclusions that don’t hold up.
  • Expecting lump sum certainty from a CM agent. The owner still carries the trade cost risk.
  • Treating open-book GMP billing like lump sum billing. The owner can audit, so cost coding and backup have to be clean.
  • Ignoring procurement rules on public work, where CM selection and trade bidding may be regulated.

The project delivery methods explainer compares design-bid-build, design-build and CM at risk with their payment bases, and the glossary covers design-build, buyout savings and general conditions. For the GC side of the work, see how to level subcontractor bids and how to calculate general conditions costs, with the general conditions calculator and the bid tabulation template.

In os.construction, a prime contract can bill by GMP or cost-plus in accounts receivable: you send the period’s costs and accounting applies the fee, checks the GMP cap against what was already billed and drafts the invoice. More for CMs is on the CM at risk page.

General information, not legal advice. Contract forms, public procurement rules and risk allocation vary by owner and jurisdiction.

FAQ

What is the difference between a general contractor and a construction manager?

A general contractor usually joins after design, prices the finished documents, signs a construction contract with the owner and holds the trade subcontracts. A construction manager joins during design to provide preconstruction services. As a CM at risk, it then commits to a guaranteed maximum price and holds the trade contracts, much like a GC. As a CM agent or adviser, it never holds the trade contracts; the owner does.

Is a construction manager the same as a general contractor?

Not quite, though they overlap. A CM at risk builds the project and holds the subcontracts like a GC, but it is selected earlier, usually on qualifications, works open-book and is paid cost plus a fee up to a GMP. A CM agent is an adviser and doesn't take construction cost risk. Many firms work in both roles on different projects.

What is the difference between CM at risk and CM agency?

A CM at risk holds the trade contracts and guarantees a maximum price, so it carries cost risk above the GMP. A CM agent advises the owner and manages the process for a fee, while the owner holds the trade contracts directly and keeps the cost risk.

Is CM at risk more expensive than hiring a general contractor?

There's no general answer. CM at risk adds preconstruction fees and usually prices with a contingency, while hard-bid general contracting pushes price competition onto the whole job. CM at risk can save cost through early estimating, constructability review and better-coordinated design, and can save time by overlapping design and construction. The result depends on the owner, the project and the market.

Can public owners use a construction manager at risk?

Many can, but public procurement rules vary. Some states and agencies need specific statutory authority to use CM at risk, and set rules on how the CM is selected and how trade work is bid. Check the procurement law that applies to the owner.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file