Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Builder's risk vs general liability: which policy pays when something goes wrong on site

Builder's risk is property insurance on the project itself while it's being built. General liability covers the contractor's legal liability to other people for injury and damage. Here is how the two differ, who usually buys each, how one fire can involve both, and the gaps contractors find too late.

Charley Forey6 min readContractsSubcontractsProject management
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. What builder’s risk covers
  3. What general liability covers
  4. A worked example
  5. Common mistakes
  6. Related reading
  7. FAQ

Builder’s risk insurance is first-party property insurance on the project itself while it’s being built: it pays to repair or replace the work and materials after a covered loss such as fire, wind or theft. Commercial general liability (CGL) insurance covers the contractor’s legal liability to other people for bodily injury and property damage its operations cause, including defense costs. Builder’s risk pays to rebuild the building. General liability pays when someone else says you hurt them or damaged their property.

The two get confused because both show up in the insurance article of the contract, both are checked at mobilization, and both can respond to the same event. They cover different property, different people and different periods, and the gaps between them are where contractors get hurt.

This is general information, not insurance or legal advice. Coverage depends on the policy wording, endorsements, the contract and the state. Confirm with your broker.

Side by side

Builder’s risk General liability (CGL)
Type of coverage First-party property Third-party liability
What it protects The structure under construction and materials for it, on site and often in transit or stored, as the policy states The insured against claims by others for bodily injury and property damage
Typical covered events Fire, wind, theft, vandalism, some water damage, depending on the form Injury to a visitor or neighbor, damage to adjacent property, completed operations claims
Who usually buys it The owner or the GC, as the contract says Each contractor, for its own operations
How long it lasts For the construction period, ending at completion, occupancy or acceptance as the policy states Annual policy, renewed; completed operations coverage reaches claims after the work is done, as the policy states
Who is insured Usually the owner, GC and subs, as their interests may appear The named insured, plus additional insureds by endorsement
Common exclusions Wear and tear, faulty workmanship itself, often earthquake and flood unless added, contractor’s tools The insured’s own work and property in its care in many situations, auto, workers’ injuries, professional liability, pollution
Proven by The policy and the contract’s insurance requirements A certificate of insurance and endorsements
One fire, two policiesA fire starts in the building under construction. One arrow points to the damaged framing and materials on the project, which is a builder’s risk claim. A second arrow points to the neighbor’s damaged building, which is a claim by a third party against the contractor under general liability.FIRE ON SITEBUILDER’S RISKREBUILD THE FRAMING,REPLACE MATERIALSGENERAL LIABILITYNEIGHBOR’S DAMAGEDBUILDING, ANY INJURIES
The same event can trigger both policies, for different losses. Which policy pays, and whether the insurers then pursue anyone, depends on the policies and the contract.

What builder’s risk covers

Builder’s risk insures the project as it goes up. Most policies cover the structure and the materials and equipment that will become part of it, on site, and often in transit and in temporary storage off site if the policy includes it. Covered perils depend on the form: “all-risk” or “special form” policies cover anything not specifically excluded, while named-peril policies list what’s covered.

Things to check in any builder’s risk policy:

  • Valuation and limit. Usually written to the completed value of the project. Adding scope through change orders can leave the limit short if nobody updates it.
  • Exclusions and sublimits. Earthquake, flood, mold, theft of unattached materials and some water damage are often excluded or limited unless endorsed.
  • Faulty work. Policies generally exclude the cost of correcting defective workmanship itself, but some cover resulting damage. The wording varies a lot.
  • Who is insured. Owner, GC and subcontractors, ideally, so the insurer can’t pursue one insured to recover a loss caused by another. See waiver of subrogation.
  • Deductible. Who pays it is usually set in the contract, not the policy.
  • End of coverage. Completion, occupancy, acceptance or expiration. Partial occupancy can end or change coverage.
  • Soft costs. Some policies can be endorsed for soft costs or delay in completion, such as extra interest when a covered loss delays the job. See hard costs vs soft costs.

The contract decides who buys it. Under the AIA A201 general conditions, the owner buys builder’s risk property insurance by default unless the parties agree otherwise; other forms and many private contracts put it on the GC. Whoever buys it, the other parties should see the policy, not just a certificate.

What general liability covers

A commercial general liability policy protects the contractor against claims from other people: a pedestrian hurt by falling debris, a neighbor whose foundation cracks during excavation, an owner’s tenant whose property is damaged. It typically pays defense costs as well as settlements or judgments, up to its limits.

General liability also has a long tail. Completed operations coverage responds to claims that arise after the work is finished, such as damage caused by a defect discovered years later, within the terms of the policy that applies. That is why contracts often require contractors to keep completed operations coverage, or additional insured status for it, for a period after completion.

What CGL generally doesn’t do is pay to fix the contractor’s own work. Standard policies contain exclusions for damage to property the insured is working on and to “your work,” with important exceptions, such as damage to completed work performed by a subcontractor under many policy forms. How those exclusions play out is a matter of policy wording and state law, and it’s an area where courts have disagreed.

On jobs with a wrap-up program, general liability for enrolled parties on site may come from the wrap-up rather than each contractor’s own policy. Builder’s risk is sometimes included in the program and sometimes bought separately.

A worked example

Illustrative: a wood-frame apartment building is framed to the fourth floor when a fire starts overnight in a stack of materials. It destroys most of the framing on one wing and scorches the siding of the occupied building next door. A neighbor breathes smoke while helping evacuate and is treated at a hospital.

  • The framing and materials on the project are a builder’s risk claim, subject to the policy’s deductible and terms. The contract says who absorbs the deductible.
  • The neighbor’s siding and the neighbor’s medical claim are third-party claims. If they are made against the GC or a sub, they go to that contractor’s general liability insurer.
  • The GC’s job trailer and tools, if they burned too, are likely covered by neither; they need an equipment or inland marine policy.
  • If the fire was started by a sub’s work, the builder’s risk insurer may look to recover from that sub, unless the sub is an insured under the policy or a valid waiver of subrogation applies. That is the point of naming everyone and waiving subrogation in the contract.
  • The schedule slips while the wing is rebuilt. Whether the delay is compensable, excusable, or neither is a contract question, not an insurance one, and soft costs such as extra loan interest are covered only if the policy includes them.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming general liability will fix your own work. It usually won’t, which is why builder’s risk exists.
  • Nobody buys builder’s risk because the owner thought the GC would, and the GC read the contract the other way.
  • Not updating the builder’s risk limit after change orders add significant value.
  • Leaving subs off the builder’s risk policy and without a waiver of subrogation, so one insured’s loss turns into a lawsuit against another.
  • Letting coverage lapse at partial occupancy while work continues in the rest of the building.
  • Collecting certificates without reading endorsements, so additional insured status or completed operations coverage isn’t actually there.
  • Forgetting tools, equipment and trailers, which usually need their own coverage.

Performance bond vs payment bond and the construction bonds explainer cover the surety side of project risk, which works very differently from insurance. In the glossary, certificate of insurance, additional insured, waiver of subrogation and subcontractor default insurance explain the rest of the insurance package, and how to prequalify subcontractors covers checking a sub’s coverage before award.

In os.construction, company admins keep an insurance register with each policy’s type, carrier, policy number, limits and dates, optionally tied to a vendor or project. Certificates and endorsements are received on the policy as evidence for a person to review, and renewal follow-ups track who is chasing each expiring policy. In Accounting, Accounts Payable holds a sub’s bill when its certificate of insurance has expired or a required one is missing.

FAQ

What is the difference between builder's risk and general liability insurance?

Builder's risk is first-party property insurance on the project under construction, typically covering the structure and materials against perils such as fire, wind, theft and vandalism. Commercial general liability (CGL) is third-party liability insurance that covers the insured's legal liability for bodily injury and property damage to others, plus defense costs. Builder's risk fixes the building; general liability answers claims from other people.

Who buys builder's risk insurance?

Whoever the contract says. Under the AIA A201 general conditions, the owner buys builder's risk property insurance by default unless the parties agree otherwise; many other contracts put it on the general contractor. On a home remodel or a small project, the contractor often buys it. Read the insurance article of the prime contract before pricing.

Does general liability cover damage to the building I'm working on?

Often not fully. CGL policies contain exclusions for damage to property the insured is working on and to the insured's own work, with exceptions such as the one for work performed by subcontractors under many standard forms. How those exclusions apply depends on the policy wording and the state's case law. Damage to the project during construction is what builder's risk is designed for.

Does builder's risk cover the contractor's tools and equipment?

Usually not. Builder's risk policies typically cover the work and materials that will become part of the structure, not the contractor's tools, equipment or trailers. Those are usually insured separately under an inland marine or contractor's equipment policy.

When does builder's risk coverage end?

When the policy says. Common triggers include completion, occupancy or use by the owner, acceptance of the work, or the policy expiration date, whichever comes first. If the owner moves in before substantial completion, check whether coverage continues for partial occupancy, because some policies end or change at that point.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file