Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Performance bond vs payment bond: who each one protects

A performance bond protects the owner if the contractor doesn't finish the work; a payment bond protects subcontractors, laborers and suppliers if the contractor doesn't pay them. Here is how they differ, how a claim works under each, a worked example and the mistakes contractors make with both.

Charley Forey5 min readContractsSubcontractsPayment
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. How a performance bond claim works
  3. How a payment bond claim works
  4. The same two bonds, one tier down
  5. A worked example
  6. When each one matters most
  7. Common mistakes
  8. Related reading
  9. FAQ

A performance bond guarantees that the contractor will complete the work under the contract, and it protects the owner. A payment bond guarantees that the contractor will pay its subcontractors, laborers and suppliers, and it protects them. Both are three-party surety bonds, both are usually written for the full contract amount, and on public work they are almost always required as a pair.

The two bonds are delivered together and often priced as one premium, so they get talked about as one thing. They aren’t. They answer different failures, protect different people and follow different claim procedures.

Side by side

Performance bond Payment bond
Guarantees The work gets finished under the contract Subs, laborers and suppliers get paid
Protects The owner (the obligee) Covered claimants down the chain
Triggered by Contractor default, properly declared by the owner Non-payment of a covered claimant
Who makes the claim The owner The unpaid sub, laborer or supplier
Typical surety response Finance the contractor, take over and complete, tender a new contractor, or pay up to the penal sum Investigate, then pay, partly pay or deny the claim
Key procedural steps Notice, often a conference, default declaration, termination per the bond form Notice and suit deadlines set by statute or bond form
Typical penal sum 100% of the contract amount 100% of the contract amount
Related protection Subcontractor default insurance, used by some GCs in place of sub bonds Mechanics lien rights on most private work
Who each bond protectsThe surety issues both bonds on behalf of the contractor. The performance bond runs to the owner and covers unfinished or defective work after a default. The payment bond runs to subcontractors, laborers and suppliers and covers unpaid amounts. If the surety pays on either bond, it seeks repayment from the contractor under the indemnity agreement.SURETYCONTRACTOROWNERPERFORMANCE BONDSUBS, SUPPLIERSPAYMENT BONDINDEMNITY
One surety, two promises to different people, and one indemnity running back to the contractor.

How a performance bond claim works

A performance bond sits in the background while the contractor performs. If the owner thinks the contractor is in default, the bond form decides the steps. Common forms, such as the AIA A312 performance bond, require the owner to notify the contractor and surety, often hold a conference, then formally declare a default and terminate the contractor’s right to complete, while agreeing to pay the remaining contract balance toward completion.

The surety then investigates and chooses a response the bond allows: finance the original contractor to finish, take over and finish with a completion contractor, tender a new contractor to the owner, pay the owner’s loss up to the penal sum, or deny liability with reasons. Owners who skip the bond’s notice and termination steps can weaken their own claim, which is why the procedure matters as much as the default.

How a payment bond claim works

A payment bond gives unpaid parties a claim against the surety’s bond instead of the property. On public projects, where liens generally aren’t available against public property, it is the main protection for the lower tiers.

On federal work, the Miller Act sets the rules. First-tier subs and suppliers to the prime can claim. Second-tier claimants, those with a contract with a first-tier sub, must give written notice to the prime within 90 days of their last labor or materials. Suit must be brought within one year after the claimant’s last labor or materials. Tiers below that generally aren’t covered. States have their own statutes, often called Little Miller Acts, and private bond forms add their own terms, so the notice deadlines and who is covered vary.

The same two bonds, one tier down

GCs often require performance and payment bonds from major subcontractors. The structure is the same, but the GC is now the obligee. A sub performance bond protects the GC if the sub defaults; a sub payment bond protects the sub’s own suppliers and sub-subs, and through them the GC, which would otherwise face claims on its own bond or liens on the owner’s property.

Bonding every sub isn’t always practical. Some GCs bond only the largest or riskiest trades, prequalify the rest, and some use subcontractor default insurance instead. Whatever the approach, read the sub bond forms as carefully as your own: notice steps and deadlines in a sub bond can be just as strict.

A worked example

Illustrative: a GC holds a $6,000,000 public school contract with 100% performance and payment bonds. Partway through, it runs out of cash.

  • The roofing sub is unpaid $180,000. It sends its claim with the subcontract, invoices and payment history to the surety, within the deadlines that apply. That is a payment bond claim. The owner isn’t the claimant, but it benefits because the roofer’s remedy is the bond, not the building.
  • The GC walks off the job with $1,500,000 of work left. The owner follows the bond’s notice and conference steps, declares a default and terminates. The surety tenders a completion contractor at $1,900,000. The owner still owes the $1,500,000 contract balance, and the surety covers the $400,000 gap. That is a performance bond claim.
  • Afterward, the surety looks to the GC and its indemnitors, often including the owners personally, to repay the $580,000 plus its costs under the indemnity agreement.

When each one matters most

Owners care most about the performance bond, but they rely on the payment bond too, because it keeps unpaid subs from pursuing the project. On private work, a payment bond can be used to keep liens off the property.

Subs and suppliers care most about the payment bond. Ask for a copy at the start of the job and calendar the notice deadlines for your tier.

GCs should treat both as debts that can come back to them personally, and manage cash, sub payments and lien waivers accordingly. Both bonds also draw on the same bonding capacity.

Common mistakes

  • Thinking of the bond as insurance. The surety expects to be repaid.
  • Owners skipping the bond’s default steps, which can give the surety grounds to deny or reduce liability.
  • Claimants missing notice deadlines, especially second-tier claimants on federal work.
  • Assuming every supplier is covered. Tiers too far from the prime usually aren’t.
  • Not asking for a copy of the bond until payment has already stopped.
  • Paying subs late on bonded jobs. Every bond claim is visible to your surety and affects how much work it will support.

The construction bonds explainer walks through bid, performance and payment bonds from bid day to closeout, and will you lose your bid bond if you withdraw your bid covers the first of the three. Estimate premiums with the bond premium calculator and capacity with the bonding capacity calculator. For how sureties judge a contractor, see what sureties look for in your WIP, and for unpaid parties on private work, notice of non-payment vs stop payment notice vs mechanics lien.

General information, not legal advice. Bond forms, statutes, thresholds and claim deadlines vary by jurisdiction and project. Read the bond itself and get advice from a construction attorney or your surety.

FAQ

What is the difference between a performance bond and a payment bond?

A performance bond guarantees the contractor will complete the work under the contract, and it protects the owner. A payment bond guarantees the contractor will pay its subcontractors, laborers and suppliers, and it protects them. Both are issued by a surety, are usually written for the full contract amount and are often required together on public work.

Who can make a claim on a payment bond?

Generally the subcontractors, sub-subcontractors, laborers and suppliers the bond and the governing statute cover. On federal work under the Miller Act, first-tier subs and suppliers to the prime can claim, and second-tier claimants who deal with a first-tier sub can claim if they give written notice to the prime within 90 days of their last labor or materials. Suppliers to suppliers generally cannot. State statutes and private bond forms set their own rules.

Is a performance bond the same as insurance?

No. Insurance pays covered losses for the insured. A surety bond is a guarantee: if the surety pays on the contractor's default, it expects the contractor and its indemnitors to pay it back under the indemnity agreement.

Do you need both a performance bond and a payment bond?

Federal construction contracts above the Miller Act threshold require both, and many state and local public owners require both under their own statutes. Private owners and lenders decide for themselves; many ask for both, and the bonds are often issued together and priced as one premium.

How much does a performance and payment bond cost?

Premiums are usually quoted as a percentage of the contract amount on a sliding scale, set by the surety based on the contractor's financial strength, experience and the job. Ask your surety agent for a quote, and use a bond premium calculator to estimate the effect of the rate tiers.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file