On this page
Usually not, if you withdraw before bid opening. Bids can generally be withdrawn up to the time the solicitation sets, by the method it allows, and the bid bond goes back to you untouched. After opening it is different: on most public work your bid becomes firm for the acceptance period, and walking away puts the bid bond at risk. The main exception is a genuine clerical or arithmetic mistake that you report quickly and can prove from your own worksheets. An error of judgment, like pricing the labor too low, almost never qualifies.
What a bid bond actually guarantees
A bid bond is a promise from your surety to the owner: if this bid is accepted, the bidder will sign the contract and furnish the required performance and payment bonds. It protects the owner from a low bidder who wins and walks.
On US federal work the standard bid guarantee clause spells this out. If the successful bidder fails to execute the contract documents or furnish the bonds within 10 days after receiving the forms, the contracting officer may terminate for default, the bidder is liable for any cost of acquiring the work above its bid, and the bid guarantee is available to offset that difference (FAR 52.228-1). Federal bid guarantees must be at least 20 percent of the bid price, up to $3 million (FAR 28.101-2).
Many private and local forms work the same way. The AIA’s description of its A310 bid bond is that the owner is paid the difference in cost to award the contract to the next qualified bidder, as long as that difference does not exceed the bond’s penal amount (AIA Contract Documents). Some solicitations and statutes instead treat the bid security as forfeited outright. Which one you face matters a lot to how much is at stake, so read both the bond and the bid documents.
Before bid opening: withdrawal is usually allowed
Until the deadline the solicitation sets, which is usually the bid opening, a bid is an offer you can generally take back. Federal rules say bids may be modified or withdrawn by any method the solicitation authorizes, as long as the notice reaches the designated office no later than the exact time set for opening, and a bidder can also withdraw in person by proving its identity and signing a receipt before that time (FAR 14.303). A withdrawal that arrives late is generally treated as late and not considered, with narrow exceptions (FAR 14.304).
Practical points:
- Use the method the solicitation allows. Some owners accept email or a portal withdrawal; some require a signed letter or an appearance in person.
- Watch the clock and the address. Notice that reaches the wrong office, or a minute late, may not count.
- Get a receipt. Keep proof of the time your withdrawal was received.
Withdrawing before opening has no effect on the bond, because the condition the bond secures, an accepted bid, never happens.
After opening: your bid is firm
Once bids are opened and prices are public, most public owners treat bids as irrevocable for the acceptance period stated in the solicitation. That is the period the bid bond exists for. Withdrawing because the number now looks thin, because a sub dropped out, or because a better job came in is exactly the risk the owner bought the bond to cover.
If the owner awards to you and you refuse to sign, or your surety will not write the final bonds, the owner can go after the bid bond. Bonding is worth checking before bid day: if the job stretches your bonding capacity, find out from your surety then, not after you are the low bidder.
The mistake-in-bid doctrine
Courts have long allowed a bidder to rescind a bid, and get the bid bond back, for an honest clerical mistake, under conditions. The classic statement comes from the California Supreme Court in M. F. Kemper Construction Co. v. City of Los Angeles (1951) 37 Cal.2d 696: rescission is available if the mistake is material, was not the result of neglect of a legal duty, enforcing the bid would be unconscionable, the owner can be put back where it was, and the bidder gives prompt notice. Kemper had left a $301,769 item off a $780,305 bid, discovered it hours after opening, and withdrew within days; the court cancelled the bid and discharged the bond (opinion). In Elsinore Union Elementary School District v. Kastorff (1960) 54 Cal.2d 380, the same court applied that test to a bid that left out the plumbing subcontract and reversed a judgment against the bidder and its surety (opinion).
The line that runs through these cases, and through the statutes below, is between two kinds of error:
| Usually qualifies (clerical) | Usually does not (judgment) |
|---|---|
| A dropped line item or a sub quote left off the recap | Underestimating productivity or crew size |
| An addition or extension error on the summary sheet | Misreading the plans or specifications |
| A transposed figure or misplaced decimal | Not visiting the site carefully |
| A total carried forward from the wrong sheet | A sub or supplier price that later went up |
Federal work: FAR 14.407
On federal sealed bids, mistakes are handled under FAR 14.407. After opening, the contracting officer examines all bids for mistakes, and a clerical mistake apparent on the face of the bid, such as a misplaced decimal, can be corrected before award once the bidder verifies the intended bid (14.407-2).
For other mistakes disclosed before award, FAR 14.407-3 sets an evidence ladder:
- Correction is allowed if clear and convincing evidence shows both the mistake and the bid actually intended. If the correction would displace a lower bid, the mistake and the intended bid must be ascertainable substantially from the invitation and the bid itself.
- Correction instead of withdrawal. If the bidder asks to withdraw but the evidence clearly proves both the mistake and the intended bid, and the bid is lowest either way, the agency may correct it and not permit withdrawal.
- Withdrawal may be permitted by an official above the contracting officer when the evidence is clear and convincing as to the mistake but not as to the intended bid, or reasonably supports a mistake.
- Neither. If the evidence does not meet those standards, the bid stands as submitted.
The bidder has to put its request and its evidence in writing, these decisions need the concurrence of agency legal counsel, and doubtful cases can go to the Comptroller General. After award, a mistake is generally corrected only if the correction is favorable to the Government (14.407-4).
State examples
State public contracting statutes set their own deadlines and proof requirements. Three examples, each summarized from the statute text:
| State | Deadline | What you must show | Catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| California, Pub. Contract Code §§ 5100–5107 | Written notice within 5 working days after opening (excluding Saturdays, Sundays and state holidays), specifying in detail how the mistake occurred | The mistake made the bid materially different and was made in filling out the bid, not an error in judgment or carelessness in inspecting the site or reading the plans | A bidder relieved of its bid cannot bid again on that project (§ 5105) |
| New York, Gen. Mun. Law § 103(11) | Before award or within 3 days after opening, whichever is shorter | An unintentional, substantial arithmetic error or omission, shown by objective evidence from the original work papers, so large that enforcement would be unconscionable | The only remedy is withdrawal and return of the bid bond; correcting the bid is prohibited |
| Pennsylvania, 73 P.S. § 1602 | Written claim within 2 business days after opening | A good-faith clerical error, such as an arithmetic error or unintentional omission | Does not apply to highway work; the withdrawing bidder cannot share in the re-awarded work without approval |
Other states, cities and school districts have their own versions, and some owners add stricter rules in the bid documents. Check the statute and the instructions to bidders for the project in front of you.
If you find a mistake after opening
Speed and paper decide most of these cases.
- Stop and check the numbers. Confirm the error from your original estimate, recap sheets and sub quotes. Do not rebuild or tidy them.
- Call your attorney and your surety. The surety has money at stake and has seen this before.
- Notify the owner in writing, fast. Follow the deadline and format in the statute or solicitation. Describe exactly how the mistake happened.
- Preserve the originals. Statutes like New York’s require objective evidence from the original work papers. Spreadsheets with version history, emailed quotes and timestamps help.
- Ask for the right remedy. Depending on the rules, that may be withdrawal, correction or neither. Federally, an agency can hold you to a corrected bid instead of letting you withdraw.
- Do not just walk away. Ignoring an award is the default the bond is written to cover.
Prevention is cheaper than relief
Most bid mistakes that end up in court are recap errors: a scope that never made it from a sub quote to the summary. A second person checking the recap, and leveling sub bids by scope before bid day, catches most of them. Our bidding explainer shows how a missing scope shows up in a leveling sheet, and the guide to construction bonds covers bid, performance and payment bonds end to end. If you want to know what the bonds will cost if you win, the bond premium calculator prices them from your surety’s own rate schedule.
Sources: FAR 14.303, 14.304, 14.407, 28.101-2 and 52.228-1 on acquisition.gov; Cal. Pub. Contract Code §§ 5100–5107; N.Y. Gen. Mun. Law § 103(11); 73 P.S. § 1602; M. F. Kemper Constr. Co. v. City of Los Angeles, 37 Cal.2d 696 (1951); Elsinore Union Elem. Sch. Dist. v. Kastorff, 54 Cal.2d 380 (1960); AIA Contract Documents on A310. Checked November 2026. General information, not legal advice.
Share this article