On this page
- Step 1: Break the package into scope lines
- Step 2: Tab every bid line by line
- Step 3: Price every gap with a plug
- Step 4: Check the math and the paperwork
- Step 5: Hold scope review calls
- Step 6: Rank the leveled totals and check the non-price items
- Step 7: Write the leveled scope into the subcontract
- Worked example: three drywall bids
- Common mistakes
- How os.construction handles it
- FAQ
To level subcontractor bids, break the package into scope lines, enter each bidder’s price and whether they included, excluded or qualified each line, then add a plug price for every gap so all bidders carry the same scope. Compare the leveled totals, not the bid totals, and check the non-price items (addenda, bonding, prequalification, schedule) before you recommend an award.
Bids almost never cover the same scope. One drywall sub excludes firestopping, another prices it, a third leaves out insulation and says nothing. Picking the lowest number on the cover sheet is how a scope gap turns into a change order three months into the job. Bid leveling is the fix, and the free bid tabulation template does the arithmetic below for up to four bidders (download the .xlsx).
Step 1: Break the package into scope lines
Before bids arrive, write the lines you want every bidder to price: the scope of work for the package, split into pieces that bidders commonly include or exclude. Pull them from the specs, the drawings and your own takeoff. Put your estimate beside each line. Then send the lines out as a bid form, so bids come back in the same shape.
Good lines are the ones that move between trades: firestopping, insulation, blocking, hoisting, cleanup, temporary protection, permits, bonds. If you only have one line, “drywall complete,” you can’t level anything.
Step 2: Tab every bid line by line
For each bidder, enter the price per line and mark the line one of three ways:
- Included. Priced, no conditions.
- Excluded. Listed as an exclusion, or simply missing from the proposal. Silence counts as a gap until the bidder confirms otherwise.
- Qualified. Priced with a condition, such as “per sketch only” or “excludes overtime.” Flag it for the scope call.
Read the whole proposal, not just the cover page. Exclusions hide in footnotes, clarifications and the boilerplate on the back.
Step 3: Price every gap with a plug
For each excluded line, add a plug so the bidder’s total includes it. In order of preference, use your own takeoff and estimate, a separate quote, or the lowest price another bidder included for that line. The last one is the template’s default. It’s quick but it’s the cheapest version of the scope on the table, so check it against your estimate when the gap is large.
Record where every plug came from. Someone will ask.
Step 4: Check the math and the paperwork
Add up each bidder’s lines and compare with the total on their proposal. Confirm which addenda each bidder acknowledged; a bid that missed an addendum is missing whatever that addendum added. Note alternates and unit prices separately so they don’t get mixed into the base comparison.
Step 5: Hold scope review calls
Call each serious bidder and walk the lines: what they included, what the qualifications mean, and whether anything they left silent is actually in their price. Ask the same questions of every bidder and keep notes. Update the tab as the answers come in, and don’t share one bidder’s numbers with another. On public or owner-controlled bids, follow whatever rules the owner sets for post-bid communication.
Step 6: Rank the leveled totals and check the non-price items
Now compare. The lowest leveled total is the price leader, but before recommending it check:
- Prequalification. Is the bidder approved for a contract this size? See how to prequalify subcontractors.
- Bonding. If the package needs a performance and payment bond, can they provide one?
- Schedule and lead time. Can they meet the dates in your schedule?
- Qualifications. Any condition you can’t accept or price.
Step 7: Write the leveled scope into the subcontract
The leveling is only worth something if it survives buyout. Write the scope you leveled to, line by line, into the subcontract, including the items the bidder confirmed on the call. Otherwise the gap you priced comes back as a change order.
Worked example: three drywall bids
The package has five scope lines. The estimator’s budget is $582,000.
| Scope line | Estimate | Bidder A | Bidder B | Bidder C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metal stud framing and board | $412,000 | $410,000 | $418,000 | $405,000 |
| Tape and finish, Level 4 | $96,000 | $92,000 | $98,500 | $94,000 |
| Batt insulation | $38,000 | $46,000 | $39,000 | $38,000 |
| Firestopping at rated walls | $22,000 | Excluded | $21,000 | $20,000 |
| Daily cleanup and dumpsters | $14,000 | Excluded | $13,000 | $12,000 |
| Bid total | $582,000 | $548,000 | $589,500 | $569,000 |
On the cover sheets, A is low at $548,000, $21,000 under C. But A excluded firestopping and cleanup. Price those gaps at the lowest price another bidder included:
| Bidder A | Bidder B | Bidder C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bid total | $548,000 | $589,500 | $569,000 |
| Plug: firestopping | $20,000 (C’s price) | ||
| Plug: cleanup | $12,000 (C’s price) | ||
| Leveled total | $580,000 | $589,500 | $569,000 |
| Rank | 2 | 3 | 1 |
Leveled, A is $548,000 + $20,000 + $12,000 = $580,000, and C, which priced everything, is lowest by $11,000. C is also $13,000 under the $582,000 budget, which is buyout savings if the scope holds.
Check the plugs against the estimate too. Using the estimator’s own numbers for A’s gaps ($22,000 for firestopping and $14,000 for cleanup), A levels to $584,000. The ranking doesn’t change, so the recommendation holds either way. When a plug does change the ranking, firm it up with a quote before you award.
Common mistakes
- Comparing cover-sheet totals. The exclusions decide the real number.
- Treating silence as included. If the proposal doesn’t mention a line, confirm it before you count it.
- Plugging with guesses. Use a takeoff or quote for any gap big enough to change the ranking.
- Missing addenda. A bid that didn’t acknowledge an addendum hasn’t priced it.
- Leveling, then writing a vague subcontract. The leveled scope has to go into the subcontract, or the gap returns as a change.
- Awarding above a bidder’s approved limit because they were low.
How os.construction handles it
Bidding runs a bid package from release to award: invited bidders price each line and can mark lines excluded, the leveling grid puts the quotes side by side, and an award recommendation recorded with a reason is approved by a different Bidding administrator. The award becomes a draft subcontract or purchase order, so the leveled lines carry into buyout without retyping. See Construction CRM, bidding and award.
FAQ
What does it mean to level subcontractor bids?
Leveling means adjusting bids so they cover the same scope before you compare them. You list the scope lines in the package, record what each bidder included, excluded or qualified, and add a price (a plug) for anything a bidder left out. The leveled totals are what you compare, not the bid totals.
How do you price an exclusion when leveling bids?
Use the best number you have for that scope: your own takeoff and estimate, a quote from another bidder or supplier, or, as a quick default, the lowest price another bidder included for that line. Write down where each plug came from so the recommendation can be checked.
What is the difference between a bid tab and bid leveling?
A bid tab is the side-by-side table of bids for one package. Leveling is the work done on it: reading exclusions and qualifications, pricing the gaps and arriving at comparable totals. A bid tab that only lists bid totals hasn't been leveled.
Should you always award to the lowest leveled bid?
Not automatically. Price is one input. Check that the bidder acknowledged every addendum, is prequalified for a contract that size, can provide any required bond, can meet the schedule and lead times, and has no qualification you can't accept.
Is it fair to call bidders about their scope?
Scope review calls are normal practice: you confirm what each bidder included and clear up qualifications. Treat every bidder the same way, follow the owner's rules on public or competitively bid work, and don't share one bidder's price with another.
Share this article