On this page
- Step 1: Put the requirements in the subcontract
- Step 2: Collect the certificate and the endorsements
- Step 3: Review each item against the requirements
- Step 4: Log every policy and its expiration date
- Step 5: Give each renewal an owner and a due date
- Step 6: Connect insurance to payment and site access
- Worked example
- Common mistakes
- How os.construction handles it
- FAQ
To track subcontractor certificates of insurance, set the requirements in the subcontract, collect the certificate and the required endorsements before the sub mobilizes, review each line against the requirements, log every policy’s expiration date, give each upcoming renewal an owner and a due date at least 30 days ahead, and connect insurance status to payment under the subcontract’s terms. Collecting a COI once at award is filing, not tracking. Policies renew on their own dates, and a sub can carry five policies with five different expirations.
What a certificate does and doesn’t prove, line by line, is covered in the certificate of insurance entry. This post is about the routine around it.
Step 1: Put the requirements in the subcontract
You can only check a certificate against something written down. The subcontract or its insurance exhibit should list:
- Coverages and minimum limits: general liability, auto, workers’ compensation and employer’s liability, umbrella or excess
- Additional insured status, ongoing and completed operations, and for whom (you, the owner, others the prime contract names)
- Waiver of subrogation and primary and non-contributory wording, where required
- How long coverage must continue after completion
- Whether the sub must flow the same requirements down to its own subs (a flow-down clause)
- What happens when insurance lapses: payment withheld, work stopped, site access refused
Start from the owner’s requirements in the prime contract. If you require less of your subs than the owner requires of you, the gap is yours.
Step 2: Collect the certificate and the endorsements
Ask the sub’s broker for the certificate, usually an ACORD 25, naming your company as certificate holder, and for the endorsement pages the subcontract requires. The certificate summarizes; the endorsements change the policy. A ticked “additional insured” box with no endorsement behind it is the most common gap.
Step 3: Review each item against the requirements
Review the certificate and each endorsement against the subcontract, and record the result:
| Check | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Named insured | The legal entity that signed the subcontract |
| Insurer and policy number | Present for every line |
| Limits | At or above the subcontract minimums |
| Policy dates | Cover the work, and completed operations if required |
| Additional insured | Endorsement attached, naming the right parties |
| Waiver of subrogation | Endorsement attached where required |
| Certificate holder | Your exact legal name |
Gaps go back to the broker in writing. Keep the rejected version: the history matters if there’s a claim.
New York’s insurance regulator has said certificates shouldn’t be used to amend, expand or otherwise alter the terms of the actual policy. The review records what the documents say; it doesn’t create coverage.
Step 4: Log every policy and its expiration date
One certificate often lists several policies with different dates. Log each policy separately, with insurer, policy number, limits, effective and expiration dates, and the evidence you reviewed for it. The expiration date drives everything that follows.
Step 5: Give each renewal an owner and a due date
A list of expiration dates doesn’t chase anyone. For each policy expiring in the next 60 days, assign one person to request the renewal certificate and endorsements, with a due date before the expiration. When the renewal arrives, review it like the original (Step 3) and log it as a new policy, keeping the old one and its evidence.
Brokers can take weeks. Ask early.
Step 6: Connect insurance to payment and site access
If the subcontract lets you withhold payment while required insurance is expired or missing, apply it consistently: check insurance status before approving each payment, and record any exception with who approved it and why. Inconsistent enforcement makes the clause hard to rely on when it matters. Tell the superintendent too: some subcontracts bar a sub from site while coverage is lapsed, and on some jobs the permit depends on it (see how to track construction permits).
Worked example
Illustrative renewal calendar for a mid-size job, as of May 1:
| Sub | Policy | Expires | Renewal requested | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ridge Drywall | General liability | May 15 | April 10 | Certificate received, AI endorsement missing |
| Ridge Drywall | Workers’ comp | May 15 | April 10 | Received, reviewed, accepted |
| Metro Electric | Umbrella | May 31 | Not yet | No owner assigned |
| Harbor Mechanical | Auto | June 30 | Not yet | Outside 60-day window |
Two items need action. Ridge Drywall’s renewed GL certificate is in, but the additional insured endorsement isn’t, so the GL renewal isn’t accepted yet: the coordinator goes back to the broker, and if it isn’t in by May 15, Ridge’s next pay application is held under the subcontract. And Metro Electric’s umbrella expires in a month with nobody chasing it; it gets an owner and a May 15 due date today.
Common mistakes
- Accepting the certificate without the endorsements the subcontract requires.
- Logging one date per sub instead of one per policy.
- Tracking expirations without owners, so everyone assumes someone else asked.
- Replacing the old certificate instead of keeping it, losing the history.
- Paying through lapses while the subcontract allows a hold, then trying to enforce it later.
- Ignoring lower tiers when the flow-down clause requires them to be insured too.
General information, not insurance or legal advice. What you require, and how you verify it, should be set with your broker and attorney. Sources: NY DFS Circular Letter No. 8 (1995), Certificates of insurance; ACORD 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance (copy published by NY DFS); NYC Department of Buildings, Permit renewal. Reviewed November 21, 2026.
How os.construction handles it
Company admins keep the insurance register, with each policy’s type, carrier, policy number, limits and dates, tied to a vendor or project, and queues for policies that are expiring or need a date review. Certificates and endorsements are received on a policy as separate evidence, and a person records the review of each; receiving or accepting a certificate doesn’t mark coverage as confirmed. An evidence review inbox shows what is waiting, renewal follow-ups give each policy one owned action with a due date, and a renewal record links the new policy and its evidence to the old one without changing it. In Accounting, Accounts Payable holds a bill when a vendor’s certificate has expired or a required one is missing, sends AP users a daily email of documents expiring soon, and accepts COIs that subs upload through the vendor portal; those uploads arrive in the register as unreviewed evidence, and the AP and insurance reviews stay separate. See insurance and compliance tracking. Reading certificates automatically is planned. If your COIs live in an inbox and a spreadsheet, start a free trial.
FAQ
How do general contractors track subcontractor insurance?
Set the requirements in each subcontract, collect a certificate of insurance and the required endorsements before mobilization, review them line by line against the requirements, log every policy's expiration date, request renewals 30 or more days before each date, and hold payment or site access under the subcontract's terms when required coverage is expired or missing.
Is a certificate of insurance enough to prove coverage?
No. A certificate is evidence that the listed policies existed when it was issued. New York's insurance regulator has said certificates shouldn't be used to amend, expand or otherwise alter the terms of the policy. Additional insured status and waivers of subrogation come from endorsements to the policy, so ask for the endorsements the subcontract requires.
How often should you collect COIs from subcontractors?
Before the sub starts work, whenever any listed policy renews, and whenever the subcontract or a project requires a change such as higher limits or another additional insured. Many GCs also confirm insurance is current before each payment.
What happens if a subcontractor's insurance expires mid-job?
It depends on the subcontract. Typical terms let the GC withhold payment, and sometimes stop work or bar the sub from site, until current insurance is provided. In some places it can affect permits too: New York City's DOB NOW permits can expire when the permit holder's insurance does.
Who should own COI tracking?
Usually one person: a project administrator, an insurance or risk coordinator, or AP. What matters is that every expiring policy has a named owner for the follow-up and a due date, and that the person approving payments can see insurance status.
Share this article