On this page
A pay-when-paid clause sets the timing of a subcontractor’s payment: the GC pays within a stated number of days after the owner pays it. A pay-if-paid clause makes the owner’s payment a condition of the sub being paid at all, so if the owner never pays, the GC may not owe it. Pay-when-paid shifts timing risk to the sub; pay-if-paid tries to shift the whole risk of owner non-payment, and whether it works depends heavily on the state.
Both clauses live in the payment article of the subcontract, often one sentence long, and they look almost identical on a quick read. The difference shows up only when an owner stops paying, which is exactly when everyone reads the subcontract closely for the first time.
Side by side
| Pay-when-paid | Pay-if-paid | |
|---|---|---|
| What it controls | When the sub is paid | Whether the sub is paid |
| Owner pays late | Sub waits for the stated period after the GC is paid | Sub waits |
| Owner never pays | Many courts require the GC to pay within a reasonable time anyway | The GC may owe nothing for that work, if the clause is enforced |
| Key wording | “within X days after receipt of payment” | “condition precedent”, “only if and to the extent paid” |
| Risk of owner insolvency | Stays with the GC | Shifts to the sub, where enforceable |
| Enforceability | Widely enforced as a timing term | Varies by state; some restrict or refuse to enforce it |
| How ambiguous clauses are read | n/a | Often treated as pay-when-paid |
What the wording looks like
These are illustrative clauses, not quotes from any standard form.
Pay-when-paid: “Contractor shall pay Subcontractor within seven days after Contractor receives payment from Owner for Subcontractor’s work.”
Pay-if-paid: “Receipt of payment by Contractor from Owner for Subcontractor’s work is a condition precedent to Contractor’s obligation to pay Subcontractor. Subcontractor assumes the risk of Owner’s non-payment.”
The second clause says, in so many words, that the risk of the owner not paying sits with the sub. Courts in states that enforce pay-if-paid generally look for that kind of clear statement. A clause that only talks about timing, or that mixes the two ideas, is often read as pay-when-paid, so the GC still has to pay within a reasonable time.
How courts tend to treat them
This is general, and the law moves:
- Pay-when-paid is widely enforced as a timing provision. Where the owner never pays, many courts have held that it postpones payment for a reasonable time rather than cancelling it.
- Pay-if-paid is treated very differently from state to state. Some states enforce a clear condition precedent. Some limit it by statute, for example by making it unenforceable in certain situations or protecting lien rights. Courts in California and New York, among others, have refused to enforce pay-if-paid clauses on public policy grounds.
- Lien and bond rights are often treated separately from the contract claim. A sub that can’t collect from the GC under the subcontract may still have a mechanics lien or payment bond claim, subject to that state’s rules and deadlines.
- Prompt payment statutes in many states set their own deadlines for paying subs once the GC is paid, and they may override longer contract terms.
The governing law clause matters too. A subcontract that picks one state’s law for a project in another state can produce arguments about which rules apply.
A worked example
Illustrative: a drywall sub bills $150,000 for March. The GC includes it in its pay app to the owner. The subcontract says the GC pays within 10 days of receiving the owner’s payment.
Case 1, owner pays late. The owner pays on May 20 instead of April 30. Under either clause, the sub is due by May 30.
Case 2, owner pays half. The owner disputes the electrical scope and pays only half of the pay app, but approves the drywall line in full. Most subcontracts tie payment to what the owner paid for the sub’s own work, so the sub is due its $150,000 less retainage. A GC that holds the drywall payment because of an electrical dispute is outside what either clause usually allows.
Case 3, owner goes bankrupt. The owner never pays the March pay app. Under pay-when-paid, the GC in many states owes the $150,000 after a reasonable time, and has to chase the owner itself. Under an enforceable pay-if-paid clause, the GC may not owe it, and the sub’s remaining options are a lien or bond claim, if they are still timely.
When each one fits
GCs often use pay-when-paid to match cash in and cash out, and pay-if-paid when they want to pass owner credit risk down the chain. If you rely on pay-if-paid, know whether it holds up in the project’s state, check the owner’s financing and payment history before you sign the prime, and keep the subcontract wording clear.
Subs should read pay-if-paid as taking on the owner’s credit risk without the owner’s contract. That may be acceptable on a public job with a strong owner and a payment bond. It is a much bigger risk on a private job with a thinly capitalized developer.
Common mistakes
- Assuming the two mean the same thing. A one-word difference can decide who absorbs a default.
- Holding sub payments for unrelated disputes and calling it pay-when-paid.
- Letting lien deadlines lapse while waiting under a pay-if-paid clause. Notice and filing deadlines usually keep running.
- Copying a clause from a form used in another state without checking whether it is enforceable on this project.
- Forgetting prompt payment rules that set a shorter deadline than the subcontract.
- Not tracking which owner payment funds which sub bill, so nobody can show what was actually received for that work.
Related reading
The glossary covers pay-when-paid, joint checks and preliminary notices. For the rest of the payment article, see how to read construction contract payment terms, and for what a sub can do when payment stops, notice of non-payment vs stop payment notice vs mechanics lien and the mechanics lien deadlines by state table. The cash flow projection template shows what a pay-when-paid lag does to your bank balance.
In os.construction, accounts payable payment runs show each bill’s payable amount with pay-when-paid terms taken into account against the owner payments received, and a pay-when-paid bill’s retainage release also needs the owner payment.
General information, not legal advice. Enforceability of pay-when-paid and pay-if-paid clauses, prompt payment deadlines and lien rights vary by state and by contract. Have a construction attorney review your subcontract terms.
FAQ
What is the difference between pay-when-paid and pay-if-paid?
A pay-when-paid clause sets the timing of a subcontractor's payment: the GC pays within a set period after the owner pays it. A pay-if-paid clause makes the owner's payment a condition precedent, so if the owner never pays, the GC may not owe the sub for that work at all. Pay-when-paid shifts timing risk; pay-if-paid tries to shift the risk of owner non-payment.
Are pay-if-paid clauses enforceable?
It depends on the state. Some states enforce them if the language clearly makes owner payment a condition precedent. Others restrict them by statute or refuse to enforce them as against public policy; courts in California and New York, for example, have refused to enforce them. Ambiguous clauses are often read as pay-when-paid.
How long can a GC wait to pay under pay-when-paid?
Usually the period the clause states after the GC receives payment. If the owner never pays, many courts read a pay-when-paid clause as allowing only a reasonable time before the GC must pay anyway. What counts as reasonable depends on the facts and the state, and prompt payment statutes may set their own deadlines.
Does a pay-if-paid clause stop a subcontractor from filing a lien?
Generally a pay-if-paid clause governs what the GC owes under the subcontract; it doesn't by itself remove statutory lien rights, and some states specifically protect lien rights from being waived this way. Whether a payment bond surety can raise the clause as a defense also varies by state. Get local legal advice.
How can I tell which clause my subcontract has?
Look for condition precedent language. Words such as 'condition precedent', 'expressly assumes the risk of owner non-payment' or 'only if and to the extent the contractor is paid' point to pay-if-paid. A clause that just says payment is due a number of days after the contractor receives payment usually reads as pay-when-paid.
Your next step
See it on one project record.
Create an account and open the sample project to see contracts, costs, changes and billing on the same record.
Try it in the appShare this article