Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

How to prequalify subcontractors: a questionnaire, a financial review and a dollar limit

Prequalification decides who is allowed to bid before price enters the picture. Set your criteria first, send one questionnaire, verify what comes back, read the financials, set single-project and aggregate limits, and re-check before every award. Here is each step and a worked example of setting a sub's limits.

Charley Forey5 min readSubcontractsRiskPreconstruction
On this page
  1. Step 1: Write the policy before you need it
  2. Step 2: Send one questionnaire to everyone
  3. Step 3: Verify what comes back
  4. Step 4: Read the financials
  5. Step 5: Set limits and decide
  6. Step 6: Re-check before every award
  7. Worked example: setting a drywall sub’s limits
  8. Common mistakes
  9. How os.construction handles it
  10. FAQ

To prequalify subcontractors, set your criteria and limits in a written policy, send every sub the same questionnaire, verify the answers (references, licenses, insurance, EMR), review the financial statements, then approve the sub with a single-project limit and an aggregate limit and an expiry date. Before each award, check the bid against both limits and the sub’s open work with you.

Sub default is one of the most expensive things that can happen to a general contractor: finishing the work with someone else, fixing what was done wrong and dealing with unpaid suppliers. Prequalification is the cheapest defense, and it works best when it’s settled before bids come in, not argued about after a sub turns out to be low.

Step 1: Write the policy before you need it

Decide what you’ll ask for, who reviews it, and how a limit is set. A one-page policy is enough: required documents, minimums or ceilings you care about (for example an EMR ceiling or a minimum years in business), how financial limits are calculated, who can approve an exception, and how long an approval lasts. If you carry subcontractor default insurance, read its requirements first; the policy usually expects a documented prequal process.

Step 2: Send one questionnaire to everyone

Use the same form for every trade so answers are comparable. The usual sections:

  • Company: legal name, ownership, years in business, licenses held and where.
  • Safety: EMR (experience modification rate) for the last three years, OSHA 300A summaries, recordable incident rate, written safety program, and who runs it.
  • Financial: reviewed or audited financial statements, bank reference, surety and bonding capacity.
  • Capacity: current backlog, largest project completed, typical crew size, and the work they have open with you.
  • Experience: similar projects with contacts.
  • Insurance: coverages and limits, confirmed with a certificate of insurance.
  • Legal: litigation, defaults, terminations and liens in recent years.

Step 3: Verify what comes back

A questionnaire is a set of claims. Check the ones that matter:

  • Look up licenses on the issuing authority’s site where the trade is licensed.
  • Get the EMR from the insurer’s or rating bureau’s worksheet, not a typed number.
  • Call two or three project references and ask whether they would hire the sub again.
  • Have the certificate of insurance confirmed by the broker, and check the endorsements your subcontract requires, not just the limits.
  • Call the surety or bank reference listed.

Step 4: Read the financials

Three ratios from the balance sheet tell you most of what you need:

working capital = current assets − current liabilities

current ratio = current assets ÷ current liabilities

debt-to-equity = total liabilities ÷ equity

Working capital is the cushion that carries a sub through slow pay and a bad month. A current ratio below 1 means current liabilities exceed current assets. A high debt-to-equity ratio means the company is running on borrowed money. Then compare backlog with revenue: a sub with more than a year of work already booked may struggle to staff another job. Note whether statements are audited, reviewed or compiled; the level of assurance differs.

Step 5: Set limits and decide

Turn the review into numbers the estimators can use:

  • Single-project limit: the largest subcontract you’ll award this sub.
  • Aggregate limit: the most uncompleted work they can have with you at once, across all jobs.

Then record a decision (approved, approved with conditions such as a bond or joint checks, or rejected), who made it and when it expires.

Step 6: Re-check before every award

At award, compare the bid with the single-project limit, and the bid plus the sub’s remaining open work with you against the aggregate limit. Check the approval hasn’t expired and the certificate of insurance is current. Then re-qualify each year when new financials arrive. A sub whose backlog has doubled since last year is a different risk.

The prequalification cycleFive steps in order: questionnaire, verify, financial review, limits and decision, check at award. A dashed arrow returns from check at award to questionnaire, for annual re-qualification.QUESTIONSVERIFYFINANCIALSLIMITSAT AWARDRE-QUALIFY YEARLY OR WHEN THE RISK CHANGES
Prequal is a cycle: the limit you set is checked at every award and refreshed each year. Illustrative.

Worked example: setting a drywall sub’s limits

Illustrative numbersA made-up subcontractor and a made-up GC policy. The multiples below are one company’s rule, not an industry standard; set your own with your surety and insurer.

The GC’s policy: the single-project limit is the lesser of 5 × working capital and 25% of last year’s revenue; the aggregate limit is 3 × working capital; EMR must be at or below 1.0, or an exception is needed.

The sub’s reviewed statements show:

Item Amount
Current assets $2,400,000
Current liabilities $1,500,000
Total liabilities $1,800,000
Equity $1,200,000
Revenue, last year $9,000,000
Backlog $6,300,000
EMR 0.86

Ratios

Measure Calculation Result
Working capital $2,400,000 − $1,500,000 $900,000
Current ratio $2,400,000 ÷ $1,500,000 1.6
Debt-to-equity $1,800,000 ÷ $1,200,000 1.5
Backlog ÷ revenue $6,300,000 ÷ $9,000,000 0.7 years

Limits

Limit Calculation Result
5 × working capital 5 × $900,000 $4,500,000
25% of revenue 25% × $9,000,000 $2,250,000
Single-project limit lesser of the two $2,250,000
Aggregate limit 3 × $900,000 $2,700,000

The EMR of 0.86 is under the 1.0 ceiling, so the sub is approved with those limits.

Six months later the sub is low on a $1,450,000 package, and still has $1,100,000 left to complete on another of the GC’s jobs. The bid is under the $2,250,000 single-project limit, and open work plus the new award is $1,100,000 + $1,450,000 = $2,550,000, under the $2,700,000 aggregate limit. The award can go ahead.

If the same sub were low on a $2,600,000 package, it would be over the single-project limit, and $1,100,000 + $2,600,000 = $3,700,000 would be $1,000,000 over the aggregate limit. The options are a performance and payment bond, a smaller scope, or a documented exception approved by whoever the policy names.

Common mistakes

  • Collecting financials nobody reads. The file looks complete and tells you nothing.
  • Taking the questionnaire at face value. Verify the EMR, licenses and references.
  • No aggregate limit. A sub can be fine on any one job and overextended across three of yours.
  • Awarding over the limit because they were low. That’s exactly the case the limit exists for.
  • Letting approvals lapse. Last year’s backlog and financials don’t describe this year’s sub.
  • Checking insurance limits but not endorsements. Additional insured and waiver requirements are in the subcontract for a reason.

General information, not legal, insurance or credit advice. Licensing rules, public-bid prequalification requirements and insurance terms vary by jurisdiction and policy.

How os.construction handles it

The Prequalification tool sends questionnaires to vendors and tracks each submission through Invited, Submitted, Under Review, Approved, Rejected and Expired, with a score, EMR, bonding capacity, trade scope, the reviewer’s decision and an expiry date. Analytics reports the prequalification approval rate and prequalifications that are about to expire. See Insurance and compliance tracking. When bids come in, how to level subcontractor bids covers the price side, and once a sub is awarded, how to track subcontractor certificates of insurance covers keeping their coverage current.

FAQ

What is subcontractor prequalification?

Screening a subcontractor's safety record, finances, capacity, experience, insurance and legal history before they're allowed to bid, and setting the largest contract you're willing to award them. The result is usually a status (approved, conditional or rejected), a single-project limit and an aggregate limit, with an expiry date.

What should a subcontractor prequalification questionnaire include?

Company information and licenses; safety data such as EMR, OSHA injury logs and the written safety program; financial statements, banking and bonding references and bonding capacity; current backlog and largest completed project; references for similar work; insurance coverages and limits; and litigation, default and lien history.

How do you set a subcontractor's single-project limit?

Use a written policy tied to the sub's financial strength, such as a multiple of working capital or a share of annual revenue, adjusted for safety and experience. There is no universal formula; the point is to set the rule in advance and apply it the same way to every sub. A bond can support a larger award than the financials alone would.

What is a good EMR for a subcontractor?

An experience modification rate of 1.0 is the baseline, roughly average for that type of work; below 1.0 means a better loss history than average and above 1.0 worse. Many GCs set a ceiling in their prequal policy and ask for an explanation and a corrective plan above it.

How often should subcontractors be prequalified?

Commonly once a year, when new financial statements are available, and again before any award that is large compared with the sub's limit or their open work with you. Track expiry dates so a lapsed prequal is caught before the award, not after.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Buyout

How to run a construction buyout: buy-by dates, a buyout log and where the savings go

Buyout turns the estimate into signed subcontracts and purchase orders. Run it as a schedule, not a to-do list: work back from each package's need-on-site date to a buy-by date, bid and level, write the scope into the contract, record every variance against the budget, and track the log weekly. Here is each step with a worked buyout log.

6 min read

Subcontracts

How to write a scope of work for subcontractors that leaves no gaps between trades

A subcontract scope of work decides who pays when something turns out to be missing. Write it from the leveled bid, name the documents it's based on, spell out the items trades argue about, and check every interface item against the neighboring trades with a responsibility matrix. Here is the method, a scope outline and a worked example that finds two gaps and an overlap.

6 min read

Subcontracts

How to track subcontractor certificates of insurance: collect, review, renew, hold

Collecting a COI once at award isn't tracking. Here is a routine for subcontractor insurance: set the requirements in the subcontract, review certificates and endorsements against them, log every policy's dates, chase renewals before they lapse, and connect it all to payment, with a worked renewal calendar.

5 min read

Open file