Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Schedule of values vs budget: billing lines and cost codes are not the same thing

The schedule of values splits the contract price into lines the owner pays against. The budget splits expected cost into cost codes the contractor manages against. Here is how they differ, why they shouldn't be the same list, how to map one to the other, a worked example and the mistakes that hide over-billing.

Charley Forey5 min readBillingJob costAccounting
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. What the schedule of values is for
  3. What the budget is for
  4. How to connect them
  5. A worked example
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Tools and related reading
  8. FAQ

A schedule of values (SOV) divides the contract sum, including the contractor’s markup, into billing lines that the owner approves and that every pay application reports progress against. A budget divides the contractor’s estimated cost into cost codes and cost types that actual and committed cost are tracked against. The SOV is revenue, organized for the owner. The budget is cost, organized for the contractor. They should map to each other, but they shouldn’t be the same list.

Both get built from the estimate in the weeks after award, often by the same person, so it is tempting to make one spreadsheet do both jobs. That works until month three, when billing is running ahead of cost on some lines and behind on others and nobody can see which.

Side by side

Schedule of values Budget
Divides The contract sum (price) Estimated cost
Includes markup Yes, in the lines or as a fee line No; profit is the gap between price and budget
Includes contractor contingency Not as a visible line on most lump-sum jobs Usually, as its own line
Audience Owner, architect, lender PM, project accountant, executives
Approved by The owner or architect The contractor’s own management
Organized by Whatever the owner wants to see: division, building, floor, phase Cost code and cost type
Level of detail Usually coarser Usually finer
Used for Monthly pay applications on the G703 Job cost reports, cost to complete, WIP
Changes when An owner change order is executed Owner change orders, plus internal budget transfers
Progress measured as Percent of each line billed Cost to date and committed cost against each code
Mapping budget cost codes to schedule of values linesOn the left, three schedule of values lines with contract values: general conditions, concrete and MEP. On the right, five budget lines with costs: Division 01 general conditions, concrete labor, concrete materials, mechanical subcontract and electrical subcontract. Lines connect each budget line to exactly one SOV line, so two budget lines roll up to concrete and two to MEP.SCHEDULE OF VALUES (PRICE)BUDGET (COST)GENERAL CONDITIONSCONCRETEMEP01 GENERAL CONDITIONS03 CONCRETE LABOR03 CONCRETE MATERIAL23 MECHANICAL SUB26 ELECTRICAL SUB
Each budget line rolls up to exactly one SOV line. The SOV can be coarser than the budget, but never split a cost code across two billing lines.

What the schedule of values is for

The schedule of values exists so the owner can pay for progress without auditing your cost. Each month the contractor reports how much of each line is complete and how much material is stored, and the owner pays that share of the line’s value, less retainage. The architect or owner reviews the SOV at the start of the job, partly to check that the values are reasonable and not front-loaded.

Because it adds up to the contract sum, every line carries some of the contractor’s markup, either spread through the values or shown as a fee line. Many SOVs also carry general conditions, bonds and insurance, and mobilization as their own lines, which the contract may limit. How to fill out a pay application and the anatomy of a pay app explainer show how the lines are billed.

What the budget is for

The budget is the contractor’s cost plan. It starts from the estimate, reconciled to the signed contract, with the fee taken out and contingency set aside. Each line is a cost code plus a cost type, such as labor, materials, equipment or subcontract, because that is the level at which costs are committed and spent. How to set up a construction project budget covers the steps.

As the job runs, the budget is compared with committed cost (subcontracts and purchase orders) and actual cost to forecast the cost to complete. That forecast feeds percent complete on the WIP schedule, which is a cost-based measure, not a billing one.

How to connect them

  1. Build the budget first, from cost codes. It reflects how you’ll buy and track the work.
  2. Build the SOV from the budget, grouping cost codes into the lines the owner wants, and adding markup.
  3. Map every cost code to exactly one SOV line. Many-to-one is fine. One cost code split across two billing lines makes comparison impossible.
  4. Add change orders to both. An executed owner change order adds or adjusts an SOV line and adds budget to the cost codes it affects.
  5. Compare monthly by line. Billed percent on each SOV line against cost percent on the cost codes behind it.

A worked example

Illustrative: a $2,400,000 lump-sum job, with a budget of $2,200,000 including $49,000 of contractor contingency.

SOV line SOV value Budget lines behind it Budget
General conditions $210,000 01 general conditions $195,000
Sitework $180,000 31 sitework subcontract $165,000
Concrete $420,000 03 concrete labor, 03 concrete materials $370,000
Framing $360,000 06 framing subcontract $330,000
MEP $780,000 22, 23, 26 subcontracts $735,000
Finishes $350,000 09 finishes subcontracts $320,000
Bonds and insurance $40,000 01 bonds and insurance $36,000
Fee $60,000 none n/a
Contingency n/a 01 contractor contingency $49,000
Total $2,400,000 $2,200,000

Planned gross profit is $200,000. Only $60,000 of it is visible as the fee line; the rest sits inside the other SOV values.

At month four, the concrete line is billed at 80%, or $336,000. Concrete cost to date is $230,000 of a $370,000 budget, about 62%. That 18-point gap is the question to ask before the pay app goes out: are the concrete values front-loaded, is material stored but not yet in place, or is the cost forecast too low? Without the mapping, the gap disappears into a job-level total where other lines happen to offset it.

Common mistakes

  • Using the SOV as the budget. Markup sits inside every line, so cost variances look smaller than they are and the fee gets spent before anyone notices.
  • Splitting a cost code across SOV lines, so billed and cost progress can’t be compared.
  • Front-loading the SOV beyond what the work supports. It invites a rejected pay app and can show up as over-billing on your WIP.
  • Forgetting the change order on one side. An executed change that reaches the SOV but not the budget makes the job look more profitable than it is, and the reverse makes it look worse.
  • Billing to the budget’s percent complete instead of to the work actually in place on each line.
  • Moving money between SOV lines without approval. Internal budget transfers are your business; SOV reallocations usually need the owner’s or architect’s agreement.

Over-billing vs under-billing explains what the gap between billing and cost means on the WIP, the WIP calculator runs the numbers, and how to bill stored materials covers the most common reason a line bills ahead of cost. The budget, commitments and cost explainer shows how the cost side fills in, and the job cost report template gives you the layout.

In os.construction, Payment Applications build the G702/G703 from the contract’s schedule of values and its executed change orders, and the Budget tool tracks original, revised and projected budget against committed and direct cost by cost code and cost type. See construction WIP software for how billing and cost meet on the WIP.

FAQ

What is the difference between a schedule of values and a budget?

A schedule of values divides the contract sum, including the contractor's markup, into billing lines that the owner or architect approves and that each pay application reports progress against. A budget divides the contractor's estimated cost into cost codes and cost types that it tracks actual and committed cost against. One is revenue for the owner's eyes; the other is cost for the contractor's.

Should the schedule of values match the budget?

Not line for line. The SOV is organized the way the owner wants to see progress and pay, and it includes markup. The budget is organized the way the contractor controls cost, often in more detail. They should be reconcilable: every budget cost code should map to one SOV line, so billed progress and cost progress can be compared by area of work.

Does the schedule of values include profit?

Yes, because it adds up to the contract sum. Some contracts, especially cost-plus and GMP contracts, show the fee as its own SOV line. On many lump-sum jobs the markup is spread through the lines instead. Either way, the SOV total is the price, not the cost.

How does each one change during the job?

The schedule of values changes when an owner change order is executed, usually by adding a line or adjusting the affected one. The budget changes for the same approved change orders, and also through internal budget transfers between cost codes, which the owner doesn't see and which don't change the contract.

Can the owner see the contractor's budget?

On a lump-sum job, usually not; the owner sees the schedule of values and pays against it. On cost-plus and GMP jobs the owner often has audit rights over actual cost, and the contract may require cost reporting in a set format. What the owner is entitled to see is set by the contract.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Job cost

Direct vs indirect costs in construction: job cost, general conditions and overhead

Direct costs can be traced to a specific job or piece of work. Indirect costs support the work without belonging to one item: the job's general conditions and the company's overhead. Here is how to draw the line, how each gets recovered, a worked estimate and the coding mistakes that distort margins.

5 min read

Estimating

How to calculate construction overhead and markup for a bid

Your markup has one job: recover company overhead and leave the profit you planned. To set it, you need an annual overhead budget, a realistic revenue volume, a profit target, and the margin-to-markup conversion most estimators get wrong. Here's the method step by step, with a worked bid and what happens to the number when volume drops.

5 min read

Billing

How to calculate retainage, and how to get it released

Retainage is a percentage of each progress payment held back until the job is done. The math is simple until a reduction kicks in, stored materials carry a different rate, or the owner releases it less a punch list holdback. Here is the formula, a six-month worked example, the release billing, and how it flows down to subcontractors.

6 min read

Open file