Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

How to review a subcontractor pay application before you approve it

A general contractor's review of a subcontractor pay application checks the contract and change orders, verifies progress with the field, tests stored materials and retainage, confirms insurance, lien waivers and other compliance, and checks the math, before approving an amount AP can pay. Here is each step with a worked review that cuts a $384,000 request to $307,000.

Charley Forey6 min readSubcontractsPay applicationsAccounts payable
On this page
  1. Step 1: Check the contract, the period and the previous amounts
  2. Step 2: Verify progress with the field
  3. Step 3: Allow only executed change orders
  4. Step 4: Check stored materials against the backup
  5. Step 5: Apply the subcontract’s retainage
  6. Step 6: Confirm compliance before it reaches AP
  7. Step 7: Check the math
  8. Step 8: Approve, adjust or return, and record why
  9. Worked example: a mechanical subcontractor’s Pay App #5
  10. Common mistakes
  11. How os.construction handles it
  12. FAQ

To review a subcontractor pay application, confirm it bills against the current subcontract and only executed change orders, verify each line’s progress with the superintendent, check any stored materials against their backup, apply the subcontract’s retainage rate, confirm insurance, lien waivers and other compliance documents are current, and check that every column foots. Then approve the amount you can support, line by line, and send the subcontractor the reasons for any change.

Subcontractor billing is usually the largest group of payments on a general contractor’s job. Every dollar approved over what’s earned is a dollar you’ve paid ahead of the work, and possibly ahead of what the owner will pay you. The owner’s reviewer will apply the same scrutiny to your pay application; the owner pay app review explainer shows what they check. Reviewing the subcontractor’s billing with the same discipline keeps the two in step.

Step 1: Check the contract, the period and the previous amounts

Before looking at progress, confirm the basics:

  • The pay app is against the right subcontract and covers the right period.
  • The schedule of values matches the approved one: same lines, same scheduled values.
  • The contract sum equals the original subcontract plus executed commitment change orders.
  • The “from previous” amounts equal what you approved last month, not what the subcontractor asked for last month.

If any of these fail, return the pay app before spending time on the rest.

Step 2: Verify progress with the field

Send each line to the superintendent, or walk it together. For each one, compare the billed percent complete to what’s in place, using installed quantities where the work can be counted: linear feet of duct, fixtures set, floors framed. Also compare against the schedule, and against what you’re billing the owner on the corresponding lines. If you’re billing the owner 60% on mechanical and approving the mechanical subcontractor at 75%, one of those numbers is wrong. The earned value calculator helps when you want to compare earned progress against cost by line.

Step 3: Allow only executed change orders

Change order lines on the pay app should match commitment change orders that are executed. A pending change, a disputed T&M ticket or a change still being priced doesn’t belong on the bill yet. Once a change order is executed, verify its progress like any other line. How to price a change order covers how it gets there.

Step 4: Check stored materials against the backup

If the subcontractor bills stored materials, the subcontract should require the same backup the owner requires of you: invoices, proof of delivery, insurance, photos and approval for any off-site storage. Don’t approve stored material the owner won’t pay you for. How to bill stored materials covers the backup and how to move it to installed.

Step 5: Apply the subcontract’s retainage

Apply retainage at the rate in the subcontract, including any separate rate for stored materials and any reduction the subcontract allows after a milestone. Check that retainage to date is calculated on total completed and stored to date. The retainage calculator and how to calculate retainage cover the arithmetic, including flow-down.

Step 6: Confirm compliance before it reaches AP

Check what the subcontract requires with each payment. Common items:

Missing documents usually mean the payment is held until they arrive, not that the work isn’t approved. Record which applies.

Step 7: Check the math

Foot each column and cross-foot each line: from previous plus this period plus stored equals total completed and stored, and scheduled value minus that total equals the balance to finish. Check the summary: total completed and stored, less retainage, less previous certificates, equals the amount due. Arithmetic errors are common and easy to fix before payment and harder after.

Step 8: Approve, adjust or return, and record why

Approve the amount you can support. Where you adjust a line, note the reason next to it, and send the approved version back to the subcontractor so their next pay app starts from your numbers. Payment timing then follows the subcontract terms, including any pay-when-paid clause. Pay-when-paid vs pay-if-paid explains how those clauses differ, and prompt payment laws in some states and on public work may set deadlines. Ask counsel if you plan to withhold beyond what the subcontract plainly allows.

Worked example: a mechanical subcontractor’s Pay App #5

Illustrative numbersA made-up subcontract with 10% retainage. Line values and field findings are examples.

The mechanical subcontract is $1,180,000, plus executed commitment change order #2 for $36,000, for a revised subcontract of $1,216,000. Previously approved work is $362,000: $210,000 on ductwork and $152,000 on piping.

Line Scheduled value Billed this period Approved this period Reason
Ductwork $420,000 $84,000 $63,000 Field at 65%, not 70%
Piping $380,000 $76,000 $76,000 Verified
Equipment, stored $300,000 $150,000 $150,000 Invoice, delivery, insurance on file
Controls $80,000 $20,000 $0 Not started
CCO #2 $36,000 $36,000 $18,000 Field at 50%
CO #3 (pending) n/a $18,000 $0 Not executed
Total $1,216,000 $384,000 $307,000

The ductwork arithmetic:

billed to date = ($210,000 + $84,000) ÷ $420,000 = 70%

field-verified to date = 65% × $420,000 = $273,000

approved this period = $273,000 − $210,000 = $63,000

The change order line: 50% × $36,000 = $18,000.

The amount due.

total completed and stored to date = $362,000 + $307,000 = $669,000

retainage to date at 10% = $66,900

earned less retainage = $669,000 − $66,900 = $602,100

less previous approvals ($362,000 − $36,200) = $325,800

current amount due = $602,100 − $325,800 = $276,300

That equals this period’s approved $307,000 less its $30,700 of retainage. The subcontractor had asked for $384,000 less $38,400 of retainage, or $345,600, so the review approves $69,300 less than requested. The job is now $669,000 ÷ $1,216,000 = 55.0% complete on this subcontract.

From billed to approved to net due on a subcontractor pay appA waterfall. The subcontractor billed 384,000 dollars. Field and contract checks remove 21,000 on ductwork, 20,000 on controls, 18,000 on the change order and 18,000 for a pending change, leaving 307,000 approved. Retainage of 30,700 leaves 276,300 due.BILLED384.0DUCT−21.0CTRLS−20.0CCO 2−18.0CO 3−18.0APPROVED307.0NET DUE276.3RET 30.7AMOUNTS IN THOUSANDS
Each reduction has a stated reason; retainage comes off the approved amount. Illustrative.

Accounts payable then confirms the insurance certificate is current, the conditional waiver for this payment and the unconditional waiver for Pay App #4 are on file, and the subcontract’s pay-when-paid clause ties this payment to the owner’s payment on your corresponding pay app. The approved G703, with a reason on each changed line, goes back to the subcontractor.

Common mistakes

  • Starting from last month’s billed amounts instead of last month’s approved amounts.
  • Approving percent complete from the office without a field check.
  • Paying pending change orders because the work was done.
  • Approving stored materials the owner won’t pay you for.
  • Missing a retainage reduction or a separate stored materials rate in the subcontract.
  • Releasing payment without current insurance or waivers, then chasing them afterwards.
  • Cutting lines without saying why, which turns the next pay app into an argument.

How os.construction handles it

On a subcontract or purchase order, a sub invoice opens with a line for each schedule of values item, with From Previous, This Period, Materials Stored, Total Completed and Stored, percent, Balance to Finish and Retainage; retainage on each line is the total completed and stored times the commitment’s rate. In company Accounting, AP matches bills to the commitment and receipts, holds bills for missing compliance documents or lien waivers, and on release re-checks pay-when-paid bills against the owner payments received. Automatic invoice checks inside the commitments tool itself are still planned. See three-way match for construction AP, retainage, lien waivers and pay apps on one record, the life of an invoice explainer, and construction accounting software. For change orders, see change order software.

FAQ

Who should review a subcontractor's pay application?

Usually the project manager checks the contract, change orders and amounts, the superintendent confirms progress in the field, and accounts payable checks retainage, compliance documents and the math before payment. Splitting the checks this way means no one person both approves the work and releases the money.

How do you verify a subcontractor's percent complete?

Compare what the subcontractor billed on each schedule of values line with what the superintendent observes in place, using installed quantities where you can. Check it against the schedule and, where the lines correspond, against what you are billing the owner for the same work.

Can a general contractor reduce a subcontractor's pay application?

Generally the subcontract lets the contractor approve the amount it believes is earned and documented, and to reject or reduce items that are not. Adjust line by line, state the reason for each change in writing and send the approved version back to the subcontractor. Read your subcontract, and ask counsel about disputes or withholding.

Should pending change orders be paid on a subcontractor pay app?

Usually not. Only change orders that have been executed and added to the subcontract belong on the pay app. Pending or disputed changes should be priced and approved through the change order process first.

What lien waivers should come with a subcontractor pay app?

A common practice is a conditional waiver for the payment being requested and an unconditional waiver for the previous payment once it has cleared, plus waivers from lower-tier subcontractors and major suppliers if the subcontract requires them. Some states prescribe statutory waiver forms, so check the rules where the project is located.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Subcontracts

How to track subcontractor certificates of insurance: collect, review, renew, hold

Collecting a COI once at award isn't tracking. Here is a routine for subcontractor insurance: set the requirements in the subcontract, review certificates and endorsements against them, log every policy's dates, chase renewals before they lapse, and connect it all to payment, with a worked renewal calendar.

5 min read

Contracts

Builder's risk vs general liability: which policy pays when something goes wrong on site

Builder's risk is property insurance on the project itself while it's being built. General liability covers the contractor's legal liability to other people for injury and damage. Here is how the two differ, who usually buys each, how one fire can involve both, and the gaps contractors find too late.

6 min read

Billing

How to bill stored materials on a pay application, and move them to installed

Stored materials let you bill for equipment and material that is bought and delivered but not yet installed. Check the contract first, get off-site storage approved in advance, send the backup with the bill, put the amount in the stored materials column, and move it to work completed when it goes in so it is never billed twice. Here is each step with a two-month worked example.

7 min read

Open file