Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Back charges: how to issue, dispute and document them

A back charge is a deduction a contractor takes from a subcontractor or supplier for cost they caused. It sticks when the subcontract allows it, notice and a chance to cure came first, and the cost is documented. Here is how to issue one, how to dispute one, and the paper trail both sides need.

Charley Forey6 min readSubcontractorsChange ordersAccounting
On this page
  1. Where back charges come from
  2. How to issue a back charge
  3. How to dispute a back charge
  4. The documents that decide who wins
  5. Worked example
  6. Mistakes that sink back charges
  7. How os.construction handles it

A back charge (also written backcharge) is a cost a contractor deducts from what it owes a subcontractor or supplier, to recover money it spent because of them: damage they caused, defective work, cleanup they skipped, or work finished after they failed to perform. It holds up when three things are true: the subcontract gives the right, the sub got written notice and a chance to cure, and the cost is documented. Miss any one and it turns into a negotiation.

Back charges are a normal part of running a job, and they are also one of the most argued-over line items at closeout. Most of those arguments are about paperwork, not about who damaged the ductwork. This post covers both sides: issuing one as the GC, and disputing one as the sub. If you only need the definition, the back charge glossary entry has it.

Where back charges come from

Back charges run downhill through the contract chain. The usual causes:

  • Damage to other trades’ work. A drywall crew dents installed duct, a lift gouges a finished floor.
  • Defective or nonconforming work the sub won’t correct, found at inspection or on the punch walk.
  • Cleanup and debris. Probably the most common and the most petty, which is exactly why it needs the same discipline as the big ones.
  • Failure to perform. Not manning the job, missing a schedule commitment the subcontract makes binding, so the GC supplements the crew.
  • Shared costs the subcontract assigns, such as a dumpster or temporary protection the sub was supposed to provide.

The same mechanism runs one level up. Prime contracts usually give the owner a similar right against the GC; for example, AIA A201-2017 lets the owner correct deficiencies after the contractor fails to start correcting within a notice period, and deduct the cost. Subcontracts copy that structure down, often with shorter deadlines.

How to issue a back charge

Back charge: from problem to deductionFive steps in a row: document the problem, send written notice citing the clause and cure period, wait out the cure period, correct the work and track the cost, then issue the back charge with a deductive subcontract change taken off the next pay app. A branch from the cure step shows that if the subcontractor cures, there is no back charge.1 DOCUMENTphotos, log2 NOTICEclause, cure3 CUREsub’s chance4 CORRECTcost on ticket5 DEDUCTdeductive COCURED: NO CHARGENOTICE DATE + CURE PERIOD = THE FIRST THING ANY DISPUTE CHECKS
Notice and a chance to cure come first. Documented cost and a deductive subcontract change make the deduction stick.
  1. Document it the moment you see it. Photos with the location in frame, the superintendent’s daily log entry, and who was working in the area. If three trades were in the room, say so: a back charge against the wrong sub is worse than none.
  2. Send written notice. Cite the subcontract clause, describe what happened and where, attach photos, say what the sub must do and by when (matching the cure period in the subcontract), and say what you will do if it isn’t done. Send it the way the subcontract requires. Log the date.
  3. Give the cure period. Most of the time the sub fixes it and there is no back charge. That is the best result for everybody.
  4. If it isn’t cured, correct it and track the cost. Use your own forces or another trade, on a separate cost code or a T&M ticket signed the same day. Emergencies affecting safety or other work usually let you act first and give notice right after, but document why it couldn’t wait.
  5. Issue the back charge with the backup: notice, photos, tickets or invoices, and the amount. Add markup only if the subcontract allows it.
  6. Enter it as a deductive change to the subcontract and take it off the sub’s next pay application, or settle it against retainage at closeout if that’s what the subcontract says. A deduction with no matching subcontract change leaves the commitment, retainage and AP out of step.

Our free back charge notice and log gives you a printable notice with these sections and a CSV log that tracks each charge from notice to deduction.

How to dispute a back charge

If you’re the subcontractor on the receiving end, a back charge is a claim against you, and you answer it like one.

  • Respond in writing, inside the time the subcontract gives. Silence can be read as acceptance.
  • Ask for the backup: the notice, its date and delivery method, photos, daily logs, tickets and invoices.
  • Check the process. Was notice given before the work was done? Was the cure period honored? Was it sent the way the contract requires? A missing step is often the strongest point you have.
  • Check causation. Show who else was in the area, your own daily reports and photos, and inspection sign-offs if your work had already been accepted.
  • Check the amount. Hours that don’t match the task, rates above what the subcontract allows, markup the contract doesn’t permit, or betterment beyond restoring the original condition.
  • Follow the dispute clause and keep working unless the contract says otherwise. Walking off over a back charge usually hands the other side a much bigger one.

The documents that decide who wins

Document Why it matters Who keeps it
Subcontract clause Gives the right and sets the process Both
Dated written notice Proves notice and the cure window GC, with proof of delivery
Photos and daily log Shows the condition, location and who was there GC superintendent; sub’s own logs too
Signed T&M tickets or invoices Proves the cost was real and reasonable GC
Deductive subcontract change Keeps commitment, retainage and AP in sync GC project accounting
Sub’s written response Shows whether it was accepted or disputed, and why Sub

Worked example

IllustrativeRiverside Medical Center is our sample project. The numbers are made up to show the pattern.

On Riverside, a drywall crew damages installed ductwork in the L2 corridor. The GC’s superintendent photographs it, notes it in the daily log with the drywall crew’s location, and sends written notice that afternoon citing the subcontract’s damage clause and its 48-hour cure period. The drywall sub declines to repair it. The GC has the mechanical sub repair it on a signed T&M ticket for $3,850, issues back charge BC-007 with the notice, photos and ticket attached, enters a $3,850 deductive change to the drywall subcontract, and takes it off the next pay app. The drywall sub disputes it, sees the timeline and the photos, and accepts.

The same charge without the notice date, sent two months later with no ticket, is a number the sub can reasonably refuse.

Mistakes that sink back charges

  • Issuing them at closeout as a pile, without the notice the subcontract required at the time.
  • Deducting from a payment without reducing the subcontract value.
  • Adding markups the subcontract doesn’t allow.
  • Back charging when several trades were in the area and nothing shows who caused it.
  • Ignoring prompt payment rules. Many states limit what can be withheld from a sub and require the withholding to be explained in writing; rules vary by state.

How os.construction handles it

The evidence lives in the project: the daily log and photos, and T&M tickets with labor, equipment and material lines and a sign-off. A back charge is entered as a commitment change order with a negative amount directly on the sub’s commitment, so the revised contract amount reflects it when the next sub invoice comes in. There isn’t a dedicated back charge record yet, so keep the back charge log alongside the commitment.

Back charges are the cost-side cousin of owner changes. For how changes move on the owner side, from RFI to ASI, CCD and change order, see from RFI to change order. For a concrete subcontractor, cleanup and damage back charges are answered from the pour-day record; see where that evidence comes from in concrete contractor software.

General information, not legal advice. Back charge rights, notice periods and withholding limits depend on your subcontract and the law where the project is. Sources: AIA A201-2017 and A401-2017, ConsensusDocs subcontract forms, American Subcontractors Association.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file