Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Markup vs margin: the pricing mistake hiding in your change orders

Add 20% to cost and you don't make 20%. You make 16.7%. The gap between markup and margin is small on one change order and expensive across a year of them. Here's the math, where it bites, and how to price changes so the number you quote is the number you keep.

Charley Forey5 min readEstimatingChange ordersAccounting
On this page
  1. The math in one line each
  2. Where it bites on change orders
  3. A worked example: CO #14
  4. The same trap in the base bid
  5. Three habits that fix it
  6. What we’re building

Ask an estimator what the company makes on change orders and you’ll often hear a single number: “We put 15% on everything.” Ask the controller what margin those change orders actually produced and you’ll get a different, smaller number. Both people are right. They’re just using different words for different things.

Markup is what you add, as a percentage of cost. Margin is what you keep, as a percentage of the price. The same dollars of profit produce a bigger markup than margin, every time. Confuse the two and you’ll quote work you think earns 15% that really earns 13%.

The math in one line each

markup = profit ÷ cost

margin = profit ÷ price

And the two convert directly:

margin = markup ÷ (1 + markup)

markup = margin ÷ (1 − margin)

A $100,000 cost with a 20% markup sells for $120,000. Profit is $20,000. That’s 20% of cost but only 16.7% of the $120,000 price. If the company plans its overhead and profit as a percent of revenue, which is how the income statement and the WIP schedule both read, the 16.7% is the number that counts.

Markup on cost Margin on price
10% 9.1%
15% 13.0%
20% 16.7%
25% 20.0%
33.3% 25.0%

Going the other way, to keep a target margin you need more markup than intuition says:

Target margin Required markup
10% 11.1%
15% 17.6%
20% 25.0%
SAME $20,000 OF PROFIT, TWO DIFFERENT DENOMINATORSCOST $100,000+$20,000MARKUP = 20,000 ÷ 100,00020.0%MARGIN = 20,000 ÷ 120,00016.7%
The profit doesn’t change. The base you divide by does.

Where it bites on change orders

On a base bid, most companies price from a margin target set by leadership, and the estimating software or spreadsheet handles the conversion. Change orders are different. They get priced fast, often by a PM, often by stacking percentages on a cost buildup. That’s where the confusion compounds.

Stacked markups. A typical owner change order adds overhead and profit on self-performed work, a markup on subcontractor cost, then insurance and bond on the subtotal. Each percentage is applied to a different base. Adding the percentages together (“10 plus 5 plus 2.7, so about 18%”) overstates what you earn, because none of those figures is a margin on the final price.

Contract caps written as markup. Many prime contracts cap change order fees, for example a percentage for OH&P on your own work and a smaller percentage on sub work. Those caps are almost always markups on cost. If your internal target is a margin, check that the contract cap even lets you reach it. Sometimes it doesn’t, and that’s worth knowing before you sign, not after the twentieth change order.

Tiered sub markups. Some contracts allow a higher markup on the first slice of sub cost and a lower one above it. Fair enough, but the blended rate is lower than the headline rate, and it drops as changes get bigger.

Deducts. On a credit change order, the owner may expect you to return markup on the deleted work. Read the contract: whether markup comes back on deducts, and at what rate, varies.

A worked example: CO #14

Sample dataRiverside Medical Center, Job #24-118. CO #14 adds fire dampers found through RFI-212. All numbers are illustrative and match our life of a change order explainer.

The cost buildup for CO #14:

Item Amount
Subcontract (mechanical sub’s change) $68,000
Supervision, self-performed $6,500
Firestopping, self-performed $3,600
Cost $78,100
OH&P: 13.5% on self-performed work, 10% on the first $25,000 of sub cost, 5% above $6,014
Insurance and bond on the subtotal $2,286
Price $86,400

Markup on cost is $8,300 ÷ $78,100 = 10.6%. Margin on price is $8,300 ÷ $86,400 = 9.6%. And the insurance and bond portion isn’t really profit: it’s a pass-through for premiums that rise with your contract value. Strip it out and the fee is $6,014, or 7.0% of the price.

None of this is wrong. The contract sets those rates. But if the job was bid at a 13.2% margin, every change order priced this way pulls the job’s blended margin down a little. On one change it’s noise. On a job with $1.1M of approved changes, it’s a real number on the WIP schedule, and it explains part of why the projected margin sits below the bid margin before anyone has made a mistake in the field.

Check your ownPull your last ten approved owner change orders. For each, divide total markup by total price. Compare the average to the margin your company assumes on change work. If you don’t have a number for that assumption, that’s the first finding.

The same trap in the base bid

The confusion isn’t limited to change orders. A bid sheet that adds “10% overhead, then 5% profit” to cost doesn’t produce a 15% margin either. It produces a price 15.5% above cost (1.10 × 1.05), and a combined margin of about 13.4% of that price. If the overhead rate came from last year’s income statement, where overhead is measured as a percent of revenue, applying it as a percent of cost under-recovers overhead on every job. The fix is the same: decide whether each rate is meant against cost or against price, write it down, and convert once. We walk through building that overhead rate and the bid markup from it in how to calculate overhead and markup for a bid.

Three habits that fix it

  1. Pick one word per number, company-wide. Estimators say markup, finance says margin, and nobody converts. Put both on every change order summary: the markup the contract allows and the margin it produces.
  2. Price change orders from the contract terms, not memory. OH&P rates, sub tiers, insurance and bond, and the treatment of deducts belong on the job record, entered once at contract setup. Then every CO on that job uses them automatically.
  3. Watch margin on changes as its own line. Track the margin on approved change orders separately from base contract margin. If change work is consistently earning less than the base bid, that’s a contract-negotiation conversation for the next job.

Our markup vs margin calculator converts in both directions, and the change order calculator builds a priced change from cost, with tiered sub markups, insurance and bond. Both run in your browser. The glossary has more on change orders, overhead and gross profit.

What we’re building

In os.construction, change orders and the prime contract are live, and change orders carry markups. Markup rules set once on the prime contract, so every change order is priced from the same terms the owner signed, are in progress. If your change orders are priced in a spreadsheet that nobody else can see, start a free trial and show us how you do it today.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Job cost

Direct vs indirect costs in construction: job cost, general conditions and overhead

Direct costs can be traced to a specific job or piece of work. Indirect costs support the work without belonging to one item: the job's general conditions and the company's overhead. Here is how to draw the line, how each gets recovered, a worked estimate and the coding mistakes that distort margins.

5 min read

Estimating

How to calculate construction overhead and markup for a bid

Your markup has one job: recover company overhead and leave the profit you planned. To set it, you need an annual overhead budget, a realistic revenue volume, a profit target, and the margin-to-markup conversion most estimators get wrong. Here's the method step by step, with a worked bid and what happens to the number when volume drops.

5 min read

Change orders

How to price a change order: labor, material, subs and markup, worked line by line

Owners review change order proposals line by line, so price them that way: define the scope, read the changes clause, cost labor at burdened rates, add material, equipment and sub quotes, then apply the contract's markups in order. Here is each step and a full worked example from direct cost to the final number.

6 min read

Open file