On this page
- Step 1: Make it safe
- Step 2: Stop disturbing the condition
- Step 3: Read the clause and give written notice
- Step 4: Document it before it changes
- Step 5: Ask for direction
- Step 6: Track cost and time separately
- Step 7: Price it and request the time
- If the owner orders the work stopped
- Worked example: rock in a footing excavation
- Common mistakes
- How os.construction handles it
- FAQ
When you find a condition that doesn’t match the contract documents, make the area safe, stop disturbing the condition as far as safety allows, notify the owner’s representative promptly in writing, and document it with photos, measurements and a daily log entry before it changes. Then ask for direction, track the extra cost and time separately from the base work, and price it through your change process. The contract’s notice clause sets the deadlines, so read it the same day.
A differing site condition is the hidden thing nobody priced: rock where the borings showed clay, an old foundation in the trench line, groundwater well above the reported level, rotten framing behind a wall in a renovation. Most contracts have a clause that moves the risk of those conditions to the owner, but only if the contractor follows the clause. The field’s first day or two decide whether that clause helps you.
Step 1: Make it safe
Before anything else: unexpected utilities, unstable ground, water, suspected contamination or unknown materials can be hazardous. Stop the affected work, keep people back, and follow your company’s procedures for the hazard. For suspected hazardous materials such as possible asbestos, unknown drums or contaminated soil, don’t keep disturbing it to find out what it is. Use your company’s procedures and the contract’s hazardous materials provisions, and get the right people involved.
Step 2: Stop disturbing the condition
The owner has a right, under most of these clauses, to see the condition before it is changed. If the excavator keeps digging out the rock, the evidence leaves in a truck. Move the crew to unaffected work where you can. If safety or the work requires some disturbance, do the minimum and document why.
Step 3: Read the clause and give written notice
Find the differing site conditions or concealed conditions clause, and the general notice and claims provisions. Note:
- Who notice goes to and in what form. A phone call or a comment at the OAC meeting may not count.
- When it’s due. Many clauses require notice promptly and before the condition is disturbed. Some set a number of days.
- What else is required, such as a later itemized claim within a set period.
Send a short written notice the same day if you can: what you found, where, when, why you believe it differs from the documents, that work in the area is affected, and that you’re asking for the owner to inspect and give direction. Keep it factual. You don’t need the cost yet; you need the notice on record.
Step 4: Document it before it changes
- Photos and video with a scale (a tape, a person, a known object), the location and the time.
- Measurements: depth, extent, elevation, quantities.
- The daily log entry: what was found, when, crews and equipment affected, who was told and when.
- The comparison: the boring logs, geotechnical report, survey or drawings that show what you expected, with the sheet or page reference.
- Anyone who saw it: the owner’s rep, inspector, engineer, with times.
A notice that says “we hit rock” is weak. A notice with “auger refusal at 4 ft, boring B-3 shows clay to 12 ft, photos attached, owner’s rep inspected at 2:15 pm” is a record.
Step 5: Ask for direction
Send an RFI asking how to proceed, referencing the notice. Propose a solution if you have one (deepen the footing, reroute the line, over-excavate and replace) so the design team can answer quickly. If the owner directs work before the price is agreed, get the direction in writing, such as a construction change directive or a written field order, depending on your contract.
Step 6: Track cost and time separately
From the moment the condition is found, track the extra work apart from the base contract:
- A separate cost code or change event number for the labor, equipment, materials and subcontract cost.
- T&M tickets signed daily by the owner’s rep where the contract allows, even if the final pricing will be lump sum.
- Idle crews and standby equipment, with hours.
- The schedule effect: which activities stopped, whether they were on the critical path, and the start and end of the disruption.
Open a change event right away so the exposure shows up in your cost reports before the paperwork is settled. Change events vs change orders explains why that gap matters.
Step 7: Price it and request the time
Once the extent is known, price the change and request any extension the contract allows. How to price a change order covers the pricing, and if the time is contested, a time impact analysis is the usual way to show the effect on the completion date. Keep the notice, RFI, daily logs, photos, T&M tickets and change event linked by number so anyone can follow the trail.
If the owner orders the work stopped
Sometimes it’s the owner who stops the work: while the engineer studies the condition, for a permit issue, or for its own reasons. Handle a stop-work order the same way:
- Get it in writing, or confirm a verbal order in writing the same day: who gave it, when, and which work it covers.
- Stop the work it covers, and only that work. Keep going on everything else.
- Protect the work in place and keep the site safe and secure.
- Record the standby: crews, equipment and subcontractors affected, and what you did to reduce cost, such as moving crews or off-renting equipment.
- Check the suspension clause for notice and claim requirements, and notify subs under your subcontracts.
- Restart only on written direction, and record the date.
Worked example: rock in a footing excavation
Tuesday, 9:40 am. The excavation sub hits refusal at about 4 ft in the footing excavation at gridline C-3. Boring B-3 in the geotechnical report, about 20 ft away, shows stiff clay to 12 ft with no rock.
- 9:45. Superintendent stops excavation at C-3 and moves the excavator to the footings at gridline A, which aren’t affected.
- 10:15. Photos with a tape for scale, depth measured at three points, extent probed with the bucket. Boring log page photographed for the comparison.
- 10:30. Superintendent calls the owner’s rep, who comes out at 2:15 pm and sees the exposed rock.
- 3:30. The PM sends written notice under the contract’s differing site conditions clause: location, what was found, the boring it differs from, photos attached, work at C-3 suspended, request for inspection (already done) and direction.
- 4:00. RFI asks whether to remove rock to design bearing or to redesign the footing on rock, with the photos and the boring log attached. A change event is opened with its own cost code.
- Daily report. Records the discovery, times, the crew and excavator moved to gridline A, the owner’s rep inspection, and the notice and RFI numbers.
On Thursday the structural engineer answers: bear the footing on the rock, revised detail attached. The sub works under signed T&M tickets for two days, the change event collects the cost, and the PM submits the priced change with the T&M backup and a short schedule analysis showing two days of delay on the foundation sequence.
Common mistakes
- Digging through it. Once the condition is gone, so is most of your evidence.
- Verbal notice only. A conversation on site is easy to forget and hard to prove.
- Waiting until you know the cost. Notice and cost are separate. The notice deadline doesn’t wait for the estimate.
- Mixing the cost into the base work. If it isn’t coded separately from day one, you’ll be reconstructing it later.
- Forgetting the schedule. Many conditions cost time as well as money. Record the time effect as it happens.
- No comparison to the documents. Your claim is that the site differs from what you were given. Show what you were given.
The change event log is a simple way to keep the condition, the notice, the RFI and the cost in one row, and T&M tickets to priced change walks through turning field tickets into a priced change.
How os.construction handles it
The superintendent can record the condition in the Daily Log from a phone browser, with photos, notes and a delay entry. An RFI asks for direction, a change event can name that RFI as its origin and carry the priced change to a change order, and T&M tickets hold the daily backup. For what to look for in a field record or RFI tool generally, see construction daily log software and construction RFI software.
FAQ
What is a differing site condition?
A physical condition at the site that differs materially from what the contract documents indicate (often called Type I), or an unusual condition that differs materially from what is ordinarily encountered in that kind of work (Type II). Examples include unexpected rock, buried foundations, unmarked utilities, groundwater well above what the borings showed, or contamination.
What should a contractor do first when finding a differing site condition?
Make the area safe, then stop disturbing the condition as far as safety and the work allow, and notify the owner's representative promptly in writing so they can see it before it is changed. Document it with photos, measurements and a daily log entry, and check the contract's notice requirements.
How quickly do you have to give notice of a differing site condition?
The contract sets the requirement. Many clauses require prompt written notice before the condition is disturbed, and some set a fixed number of days. Late or missing notice can weaken or defeat a claim, so treat the clause as a deadline and get advice if you're unsure.
Can you keep working after finding a differing site condition?
Often you continue with unaffected work, and sometimes with the affected work once the owner has had a chance to inspect and has given direction. Many contracts require the contractor to keep working while a dispute is resolved. Don't remove or cover the condition before the owner has had the chance to see it, unless safety requires it, and document what you did and why.
Is a differing site condition the same as a change order?
No. The differing site condition is the event. If the owner agrees the condition qualifies, the cost and time effect is normally added to the contract through a change order. Until then, track it as a change event or potential change so the cost and time aren't lost.
Share this article