Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Holdback vs retainage: Canadian prompt payment for US contractors

Holdback is Canada's statutory cousin of retainage. In Ontario every payer holds back 10 percent by law, invoices run on a 28-day clock, and since January 2026 holdback comes out every year. What US contractors need to change before billing their first Ontario job.

Charley Forey7 min readBillingPaymentCanada
On this page
  1. Holdback vs retainage at a glance
  2. The Ontario prompt payment clock
  3. How holdback is released
  4. Worked example (illustrative)
  5. US terms and their Canadian equivalents
  6. What to change before your first Ontario job
  7. How os.construction handles it

Holdback is the Canadian version of retainage, with one big difference: it is set by statute, not by the contract. In Ontario, the Construction Act requires every payer on a project, the owner, the general contractor and each subcontractor that has subs of its own, to hold back 10 percent of the value of the work as security for the lower tiers’ lien rights. In the US, retainage is a contract term, its rate is negotiated, and statutes only cap or time it on some jobs. Ontario also puts every invoice on a fixed prompt payment clock: the owner pays a proper invoice within 28 days unless it disputes it in writing within 14, and each tier pays the next within 7 days of being paid.

If you’re a US contractor bidding or billing in Ontario, the vocabulary looks familiar and the mechanics are not. This post maps one to the other.

Not legal adviceThis post covers Ontario’s Construction Act as amended to January 1, 2026, in general terms. Every province has its own lien and holdback statute, several have their own prompt payment regimes, and federal projects have a separate one. Read the Act and talk to an Ontario construction lawyer before relying on any timeline here.

Holdback vs retainage at a glance

US retainage Ontario holdback
Source The contract The Construction Act
Rate Negotiated; 5% and 10% are common; capped by statute on some jobs 10% of the value of services or materials supplied
Who must hold it Whoever the contract says Every payer in the pyramid with lower tiers below it
What it protects The owner’s security for completion, by contract The lien rights of subs and suppliers below
When it is released When the contract says, often at substantial and final completion After the lien period expires, and now annually on longer contracts
Can it be used for set-off? Often, if the contract allows Not against deficiency claims; the 2026 amendments removed the notice that allowed withholding it
Proof everyone was paid Lien waivers from each tier Commonly a statutory declaration of payment, plus the lien period running out

The Ontario prompt payment clock

Ontario’s prompt payment rules came into force on October 1, 2019, and apply to contracts and subcontracts on private and public projects. They start with a proper invoice, a written bill that contains the information the Act lists (who is billing, the contract, the period, the work, the amount and payment terms, and who gets paid). Everything else runs from the day the owner receives it.

Ontario prompt payment timeline and the 10 percent holdbackA timeline from day 0 to day 42. On day 0 the contractor gives the owner a proper invoice. By day 7 the owner must flag any deficiencies or the invoice is deemed proper. By day 14 the owner must give any notice of non-payment. By day 28 the owner pays the undisputed amount. Within 7 days of being paid, the contractor pays its subcontractors, about day 35 if the owner paid on day 28. Below, each payment is split: 90 percent flows down, 10 percent is held back as statutory holdback until the lien period runs out, or at each annual release.PROMPT PAYMENT CLOCK · ONTARIODay 0InvoicedeliveredDay 7DeficiencynoticeDay 14Notice ofnon-paymentDay 28OwnerpaysDay 35SubspaidEVERY PAYMENT, SPLIT90% paid down the chain10%Holdback is kept by every payer in the pyramid,then released once lien rights expire or at eachannual release. Rules vary by province.
Ontario's statutory clock as amended to January 1, 2026. The contract can't stretch it, and the 10% holdback isn't negotiable.
  • Day 7: deficiency notice. Since January 1, 2026, an invoice is deemed a proper invoice unless, within 7 days of receiving it, the owner gives the contractor written notice of what is missing or wrong.
  • Day 14: owner’s notice of non-payment. To pay less than the full invoice, the owner must give the contractor a notice of non-payment, in the prescribed form, within 14 days of receiving the proper invoice, stating the amount it won’t pay and why.
  • Day 28: owner pays. Whatever isn’t disputed is due no later than 28 days after the owner received the proper invoice.
  • Day 28 + 7: subs paid. Once paid, the contractor must pay each subcontractor whose work was in that invoice within 7 days. If the contractor won’t pay a sub in full, it must give the sub its own notice of non-payment by the earlier of 7 days after receiving the owner’s notice or 35 days after it gave its proper invoice, and in some cases undertake to refer the dispute to adjudication within 21 days.
  • And so on down. Sub-subcontractors get the same treatment one level down, with the outside date pushed to 42 days.

Notice the direction. In Ontario a “notice of non-payment” comes from the payer disputing an invoice. In the US the same phrase usually means a notice from the unpaid party; see notice of non-payment vs stop payment notice vs mechanics lien.

Disputes go to adjudication, a fast, interim decision by a certified adjudicator that is binding until a court or arbitrator decides otherwise. Payment generally has to follow an adjudicator’s determination quickly, so it is not a process to ignore.

How holdback is released

Holdback sits until lien rights below it have run out. In Ontario a lien generally must be preserved within 60 days of an event such as the publication of a certificate of substantial performance or the completion or abandonment of the contract. Once that period passes with no lien preserved, or with liens that have been dealt with, the holdback is paid and flows down the pyramid.

The January 1, 2026 amendments added an annual release. For each year of a contract, the owner must publish a notice of annual release of holdback within 14 days of the contract’s anniversary, then pay the accrued holdback after 60 days, and no later than 74 days, following publication, unless liens have been preserved. Each contractor and subcontractor then has 14 days after receiving annual holdback to release it to the next tier. For contracts entered before 2026, the first annual release falls on the second contract anniversary after January 1, 2026. The amendments also repealed the owner’s ability to withhold holdback by publishing a notice of non-payment of holdback, so deficient-work claims can no longer be set off against it.

The amendments apply to contracts regardless of when they were signed, except where the procurement started or the contract was entered before July 1, 2018, which stays under the old Construction Lien Act. Certain public-private partnership projects also stay under the old holdback rules.

Worked example (illustrative)

A US drywall sub working for a GC on an Ontario office project bills $200,000 for October. The numbers are made up:

  • Holdback: 10% of $200,000 = $20,000 is held back by the GC. The owner holds back 10% of the GC’s own invoice in the same way.
  • Clock: the GC gives the owner its proper invoice on November 3. The owner flags no deficiencies by November 10 and gives no notice of non-payment by November 17, so it must pay by December 1.
  • Pay down: the GC is paid December 1 and must pay the sub its $180,000 by December 8.
  • Holdback release: the $20,000 waits for the lien period after substantial performance, or the next annual release if the contract runs past its anniversary.

A US sub used to “pay when paid, eventually” and a 10% retainage held until closeout finds the Ontario version faster on progress payments and more predictable on holdback, but strict on paperwork.

US terms and their Canadian equivalents

United States Canada (Ontario usage)
Retainage Holdback (basic holdback; a separate finishing holdback for late finishing work)
Pay application Progress draw, progress claim or proper invoice
Mechanics lien Construction lien
Substantial completion Substantial performance (with a published certificate)
Lien waiver Statutory declaration of payment (common practice)
Notice of nonpayment (from the unpaid party) No direct equivalent; Ontario’s notice of non-payment comes from the payer
Pay-when-paid clause Limited by the statutory payment clock

What to change before your first Ontario job

  1. Rebuild the billing calendar around the 28-day clock. Your sub pay apps have to land early enough for your proper invoice to go in complete.
  2. Use a proper-invoice template that carries every item the Act requires. A deficient invoice now gets 7 days of grace, not the full clock.
  3. Track holdback as its own balance, receivable from the owner and payable to subs, at 10%, with release dates tied to the lien period and annual anniversaries.
  4. Calendar the notices. Your own notices of non-payment to subs have fixed deadlines; missing one generally means paying in full.
  5. Plan for adjudication. Know who will run it, because a notice that undertakes to adjudicate commits you to start within 21 days.
  6. Read the trust provisions. Money a contractor receives on account of the contract price is held in trust for the subs and suppliers below it until they are paid.

How os.construction handles it

In os.construction, payment applications calculate retainage per line, on completed work and stored materials, at the percentage you set, so a 10% holdback is entered the same way as retainage. In the Accounting module, Accounts Receivable tracks retainage receivable by contract and Accounts Payable holds retainage payable per bill line and releases it with its own posting. os.construction does not calculate Ontario prompt payment deadlines, publish holdback notices or run adjudication. The US side of the payment chain is in the getting paid guide, and you can model holdback percentages with the retainage calculator.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Billing

Notice of non-payment vs stop payment notice vs mechanics lien

A notice of non-payment warns people, a stop payment notice freezes the money and a mechanics lien attaches to the property. What each one does, who sends it, the deadlines in California, Florida and Texas, and what a GC should do when one lands.

6 min read

Billing

How to bill stored materials on a pay application, and move them to installed

Stored materials let you bill for equipment and material that is bought and delivered but not yet installed. Check the contract first, get off-site storage approved in advance, send the backup with the bill, put the amount in the stored materials column, and move it to work completed when it goes in so it is never billed twice. Here is each step with a two-month worked example.

7 min read

Cash flow

How to build a construction cash flow projection: from the cost curve to the month you're lowest

A job's cash flow projection moves every dollar of billing and cost to the month it's actually paid. Spread cost by month, bill it, delay the receipts by the owner's payment terms and retainage, time each kind of cost by its own terms, then run the cumulative total to find the peak cash need. Here is each step and a worked eight-month example.

5 min read

Open file