Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Earned value vs percent complete: one measures progress, the other tells you what it means

Percent complete says how much of the work is done. Earned value turns that progress into the budgeted value of the work done, so it can be compared with the plan and with what was spent. Here is how the two relate, when to use each, a worked example and the mistakes that make every job look on budget.

Charley Forey5 min readProject controlsSchedulingJob cost
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. Percent complete: many ways to measure one thing
  3. Earned value: percent complete with a price on it
  4. When to use each
  5. A worked example
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Tools and related reading
  8. FAQ

Percent complete is the share of a piece of work that is done, measured by installed quantities, milestones, duration or cost. Earned value is the budgeted value of that completed work: percent complete multiplied by the budget for the same scope. Percent complete tells you how far along the work is. Earned value lets you compare that progress with what you planned to have done (planned value) and what you actually spent (actual cost), which is what turns a progress number into a cost and schedule verdict.

So they aren’t competitors. Percent complete is an input to earned value. The confusion comes from treating a percent complete number as if it already said something about performance, or from calculating it in a way that makes earned value meaningless.

Side by side

Percent complete Earned value (EV)
What it is Share of the work done Budgeted value of the work done
Unit Percent Dollars or hours
Formula Depends on the method: units installed ÷ total, milestones reached, cost ÷ estimate Percent complete × budget at completion
Answers How far along is it? How does progress compare with plan and with cost?
Needs a budget No Yes
Needs a baseline No For planned value and schedule variance, yes
Rolls up by Weighting, which is easy to get wrong Adding dollars
Drives Field reporting, billing discussions, WIP revenue when cost-based CPI, SPI, cost and schedule variance, forecasts of cost at completion
Common trap Averaging percentages of unequal activities Using cost-based percent complete, so EV always equals actual cost
Percent complete becomes earned value, which is compared with plan and costPercent complete multiplied by the budget at completion gives earned value. Earned value is then compared with planned value to get schedule performance, and with actual cost to get cost performance.PERCENTCOMPLETEBUDGET ATCOMPLETIONEARNEDVALUEVS PLANNED VALUESPI = EV / PVVS ACTUAL COSTCPI = EV / ACPERCENT COMPLETE MUST NOT COME FROM COST, OR CPI IS ALWAYS 1.00
Percent complete feeds earned value. The comparison with plan and cost is where the information is.

Percent complete: many ways to measure one thing

Percent complete is only as good as its measurement method. Common ones:

  • Physical or units. Installed quantities against total quantities: cubic yards placed, linear feet of pipe, devices set. The most direct measure when quantities are tracked. See units percent complete.
  • Weighted milestones. Credit for defined steps, such as rough-in 40%, trim 30%, test 30%.
  • Duration. Elapsed working days over planned duration. Easy, but it measures time passing, not work done.
  • Cost-to-cost. Cost to date over estimated total cost. The standard input method for recognizing revenue on the WIP schedule, and a poor choice for earned value.
  • Judgment. The foreman’s estimate. Fine for a quick read, risky as the basis for anything you report.

Rolling percent complete up is where it most often goes wrong. Two activities, one worth $10,000 and 90% done and one worth $190,000 and 10% done, average to 50%. Weighted by budget, they are 14% done. A schedule that rolls up by simple average or by duration can report a number that has little to do with the money.

Earned value: percent complete with a price on it

Earned value multiplies percent complete by the budget at completion (BAC) for the same scope, usually at the level of a control account or activity. Then it’s compared with two other numbers:

  • Planned value (PV): the budgeted value of the work the baseline said should be done by the data date.
  • Actual cost (AC): what the work done has actually cost.

From those three, schedule variance is EV − PV, cost variance is EV − AC, the schedule performance index (SPI) is EV ÷ PV and the cost performance index (CPI) is EV ÷ AC. The earned value step-by-step explainer walks through each one with charts.

How percent complete becomes EV is set by the earned value technique: percent complete, 0/100, 50/50, weighted milestones and others. The same activity can show very different EV under different techniques, so reports should say which one they use.

When to use each

Use percent complete on its own for field conversations and quick status: “framing on level 3 is about 60% done.” It is also the right language for the pay application, where each schedule of values line is billed by the share of work in place.

Use earned value when you need to judge performance: is this scope costing more than budgeted, and is it behind the plan? EV is what makes a monthly cost report or an owner report say more than “we’ve spent 47% of the budget.”

Use cost-to-cost percent complete for revenue recognition on the WIP schedule, where accounting standards expect a consistent input or output method. Don’t reuse it as the progress measure for earned value. Cost-to-cost percent complete: when it lies covers its own failure modes.

A worked example

Illustrative: a drywall control account has a budget at completion of $200,000. At the end of month three:

Measure Value
Planned by the baseline 50%, so PV = $100,000
Physically installed 40%, so EV = $80,000
Actual cost to date $95,000
Cost variance (EV − AC) −$15,000
Schedule variance (EV − PV) −$20,000
CPI (EV ÷ AC) 0.84
SPI (EV ÷ PV) 0.80

The scope is behind plan and running over cost. A simple forecast of cost at completion, BAC ÷ CPI, is about $237,500, or $37,500 over budget. See estimate at completion for other ways to forecast it.

Now calculate percent complete from cost instead: $95,000 ÷ $200,000 = 47.5%. Earned value becomes $95,000, exactly equal to actual cost. CPI is 1.00 and SPI is 0.95. The same scope now looks on budget and only slightly behind, and the overrun won’t appear until the budget runs out with work still left.

Common mistakes

  • Deriving percent complete from cost, which makes CPI 1.00 by definition.
  • Averaging percentages across activities of different size instead of adding earned dollars.
  • Using duration percent complete as physical progress, so a stalled activity keeps earning value as days pass.
  • Comparing EV with a budget that has moved without updating planned value, or without an approved baseline at all.
  • Reading SPI late in the job. Cost-based SPI tends toward 1.00 as work finishes, even on late jobs. Time-based measures such as SPI(t) avoid that.
  • Mixing up WIP percent complete and earned value in the same report without saying which is which.

The earned value calculator and EAC calculator run the numbers, the critical path explainer covers the schedule side of “behind plan,” and how to track labor productivity covers measuring installed quantities in the field.

In os.construction, the schedule’s period performance and earned value tools calculate earned value from resource assignments with the earned value technique you choose, and store each period’s actuals, earned value and planned value. In Analytics, earned value reports CPI, SPI, TCPI, VAC and EAC from schedule progress and job cost, and stays blank until the schedule has a baseline. See construction scheduling software.

FAQ

What is the difference between earned value and percent complete?

Percent complete is the share of a piece of work that is done, measured by installed quantities, milestones, duration or cost. Earned value is the budgeted value of that completed work: percent complete multiplied by the budget for the same scope. Percent complete answers how far along the work is; earned value lets you compare that progress with the planned value and the actual cost.

How do you calculate earned value from percent complete?

Multiply the percent complete by the budget at completion for the same scope. If a $200,000 control account is 40% complete, its earned value is $80,000. Roll up earned value by adding the dollars, not by averaging percentages.

Why is my CPI always 1.00?

Usually because percent complete is being calculated from cost: cost to date divided by budget. Then earned value equals actual cost by definition, and the cost performance index can't show an overrun. Earned value needs a progress measure that is independent of cost, such as installed quantities or weighted milestones.

Is the percent complete on my WIP schedule the same as earned value?

No. The WIP schedule usually uses cost-to-cost percent complete, against the current estimated total cost, to recognize contract revenue. Earned value usually measures physical progress against a fixed budget baseline to evaluate performance. Both are useful, and they answer different questions.

Do I need a baseline to use earned value?

Yes. Planned value comes from a baseline: the budget spread over the baseline schedule. Without one you can still calculate earned value and compare it with actual cost, but you can't measure schedule performance against a plan.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Keep readingAll articles →
Scheduling

How to calculate liquidated damages exposure and carry it in your forecast

Liquidated damages exposure is the days between your forecast finish and the adjusted contract date, times the daily rate, for each milestone that carries LDs, limited by any cap. The hard part is using honest inputs: approved extensions only, a forecast from the current schedule, pending requests and risk shown as separate scenarios. Here is the method and a worked example with two milestones.

7 min read

Scheduling

How to create a work breakdown structure for a construction project

A work breakdown structure splits the whole scope of a job into pieces you can schedule, budget and measure. Choose the split that matches how the job will be built, decompose to work packages one party can own, check the 100% rule, write a WBS dictionary, then tie the WBS to cost codes and schedule activities. Here is the method and a worked example for a three-story office building.

6 min read

Budget

How to set up a construction project budget: from the awarded estimate to a locked original

A project budget is the awarded estimate restated as cost lines you will actually track. Reconcile the estimate to the signed contract, take out the fee, load each cost code and cost type, give general conditions and contingency their own lines, lock the original, and from then on change it only through recorded budget changes and transfers. Here is each step with a worked $4.85 million example.

6 min read

Keep exploring

Related across os.construction

Open file