Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Percentage of completion vs completed contract method: how contractors recognize revenue

The percentage of completion method recognizes contract revenue as the work progresses; the completed contract method waits until the job is done. Here is how each one works, where each is allowed for books and for tax, a worked example on one job and the mistakes that distort a contractor's results.

Charley Forey5 min readAccountingWIPFinancials
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. How percentage of completion works
  3. How completed contract works
  4. A worked example
  5. When each one fits
  6. Common mistakes
  7. Related reading
  8. FAQ

The percentage of completion method recognizes contract revenue and gross profit as the work progresses, usually in proportion to cost incurred over total estimated cost. The completed contract method recognizes nothing on the income statement while the job is underway and then recognizes all of the revenue and profit when the contract is complete. Most contractors use percentage of completion for financial statements, and some smaller contractors use completed contract for taxes where IRC Section 460 allows it.

The choice doesn’t change how much a job makes. It changes when the profit shows up, which affects taxes, how the financial statements look to a surety or lender, and whether anyone notices a job going bad before it is finished.

Side by side

Percentage of completion Completed contract
Revenue recognized Each period, as work progresses All at once, when the contract is complete
Typical progress measure Cost-to-cost: cost to date ÷ estimated total cost None needed until completion
Balance sheet while in progress Over-billings or under-billings against earned revenue Costs and billings accumulate; the net shows as costs in excess of billings or billings in excess of costs
Income pattern Smooth, follows the work Lumpy, follows job closings
Depends on estimates Heavily; a bad cost-to-complete distorts earned revenue Less during the job; all at the end
Financial statements (GAAP) Consistent with ASC 606 over-time recognition for most construction contracts Not a named method under ASC 606
Tax (IRC 460) Required for long-term contracts unless exempt Allowed for exempt contracts, such as small contractors’ short jobs and home construction
Expected losses (books) Recognized as soon as probable Recognized as soon as probable
Gross profit recognized by year under each methodA two-year, 1.2 million dollar contract with 200,000 dollars of expected gross profit. Under percentage of completion, 80,000 dollars of gross profit is recognized in year one and 120,000 dollars in year two. Under completed contract, nothing is recognized in year one and all 200,000 dollars in year two.80K120K0200KYEAR 1YEAR 2YEAR 1YEAR 2PERCENTAGE OF COMPLETIONCOMPLETED CONTRACT
Same job, same total profit. Only the timing changes. Illustrative numbers from the example below.

How percentage of completion works

Each period, the contractor estimates how far along each contract is, usually with the cost-to-cost method: cost incurred to date divided by total estimated cost. That percent complete times the contract value is earned revenue to date. Compare earned revenue with what has been billed, and the difference is an over-billing (billed ahead of the work) or an under-billing (work ahead of billing). The WIP schedule does this job by job.

For financial statements, ASC 606 is the governing standard. Most construction contracts meet its criteria for recognizing revenue over time, and cost-to-cost is a common input measure of progress, so the result looks much like traditional percentage of completion. The quality of the number depends entirely on the estimate at completion. If the estimate is stale, earned revenue is wrong, and so is the over/under-billing. Cost-to-cost percent complete: when it lies covers the common distortions.

How completed contract works

Under the completed contract method, costs and billings build up on the balance sheet while the job runs, and nothing reaches revenue or cost of revenue. When the contract is complete, all the revenue and all the cost are recognized together.

Its main home today is tax. IRC Section 460 generally requires percentage of completion for long-term contracts, meaning contracts not finished in the tax year they start. Two exceptions matter most: home construction contracts, and contracts of small contractors under an inflation-adjusted gross receipts threshold that are expected to be completed within two years. Exempt contracts can use completed contract and other permissible methods. The rules, thresholds and recent changes to the residential exemptions have details that matter, so treat this as orientation and check with your CPA.

That means a contractor can keep books on ASC 606 for its financial statements and report taxes on completed contract, tracking the difference as a book-tax difference.

A worked example

Illustrative: a $1,200,000 contract with an estimated total cost of $1,000,000, so $200,000 of expected gross profit. It starts in the spring and finishes the next summer. By year end, cost incurred is $400,000 and billings are $520,000.

End of year one Percentage of completion Completed contract
Percent complete 40% ($400,000 ÷ $1,000,000) n/a
Revenue recognized $480,000 $0
Cost recognized $400,000 $0
Gross profit recognized $80,000 $0
Balance sheet $40,000 over-billing ($520,000 billed less $480,000 earned) $120,000 billings in excess of costs

If the job finishes on estimate, year two recognizes the remaining $720,000 of revenue and $120,000 of gross profit under percentage of completion, and the full $1,200,000 and $200,000 under completed contract.

Now suppose that at the end of year one the estimate at completion rises to $1,250,000, a $50,000 loss. For financial statements, the expected loss is recognized right away under either method. Waiting for completion to show a known loss is one of the most common and most serious errors in contractor financials.

When each one fits

Percentage of completion fits financial statements for most contractors, and it is what sureties, banks and bonding agents expect to see in the WIP. It is also the method that tells management, month by month, which jobs are fading.

Completed contract fits tax reporting for contractors that qualify, typically to defer tax on profit until jobs close. It also fits very short jobs, where the timing difference is small. As a management tool it is weak: it tells you a job lost money after it is over.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing book and tax methods. The tax return can use completed contract while the financial statements follow ASC 606. They are different reports.
  • Deferring a known loss until the job finishes.
  • Stale estimates. Percentage of completion is only as good as the cost-to-complete review behind it.
  • Front-loaded progress. Counting material delivered but not installed, or a large mobilization cost, as progress can overstate earned revenue.
  • Assuming the small contractor exception lasts. It ends once average gross receipts pass the threshold, and changing methods involves IRS filings.
  • Showing a surety completed-contract statements without a percentage-of-completion WIP to go with them.

See how to prepare a WIP schedule, over-billing vs under-billing and what sureties look for in your WIP. The WIP calculator runs the percentage-of-completion math for one job, and the glossary covers loss provisions and revenue recognition.

In os.construction, the WIP app computes an ASC 606 percent-complete WIP from posted job cost, posted billings and frozen forecasts, cost-to-cost unless a job is set to as-invoiced, and posts over- and under-billings and loss provisions after a second person approves.

General information, not tax or accounting advice. Revenue recognition and tax method rules depend on your facts and change over time. Confirm methods with your CPA.

FAQ

What is the difference between percentage of completion and completed contract method?

The percentage of completion method recognizes a share of contract revenue and gross profit each period as the work progresses, usually measured by cost incurred to date over total estimated cost. The completed contract method recognizes nothing until the contract is complete, then recognizes all of the revenue and profit at once.

Can contractors still use the completed contract method under GAAP?

ASC 606 doesn't name a completed contract method. It recognizes revenue over time when a contract meets the over-time criteria, which most construction contracts do, and at a point in time when it doesn't. Point-in-time recognition can look similar to completed contract, but it is a result of the criteria, not a free choice. Ask your CPA how it applies to your contracts.

Who can use the completed contract method for taxes?

Under IRC Section 460, long-term contracts generally must use the percentage of completion method. The main exceptions are home construction contracts and small contractors whose average annual gross receipts are under an inflation-adjusted threshold, for contracts expected to be completed within two years. Exempt contracts can use other permissible methods, including completed contract.

Why do sureties want percentage of completion?

Because it shows how each job is performing while it is underway. A WIP schedule built on percentage of completion shows earned revenue, gross profit, over-billing and under-billing job by job. Completed contract hides all of that until the job closes, which makes it hard to judge whether the contractor can take on more work.

Are losses recognized differently under the two methods?

For financial statements, an expected loss on a contract is recognized as soon as it becomes probable, whichever method is used for revenue. Tax rules for losses are different and depend on the method, so confirm the tax treatment with your CPA.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file