Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Commissioning (Cx) for general contractors: who does what, when

Commissioning checks that building systems are installed, tested and able to run the way the owner needs. What ASHRAE Standard 202, Guideline 0 and LEED's commissioning prerequisite expect, and what the GC, the trades, the CxA and the design team each own from design to the warranty year.

Charley Forey6 min readProject managementCloseout
On this page
  1. The standards behind Cx
  2. The vocabulary you’ll see
  3. Who does what
  4. When it happens
  5. Where it goes wrong for the GC
  6. How Cx fits into closeout
  7. Sources

Commissioning (Cx) is a quality process that verifies a building’s systems are designed, installed, tested and able to operate to the owner’s project requirements. The owner hires a commissioning authority (CxA) to run it. The general contractor doesn’t run commissioning, but it carries most of the work that makes it pass: getting systems started up, the trades’ checklists done, test and balance finished, and the right people on site for functional tests. On most jobs that work lands in the last eight weeks, which is exactly when the schedule has no room for it.

Here is how the process is defined, who owns each piece, and where it usually goes wrong for the GC.

The standards behind Cx

Three documents shape most commercial commissioning in the US:

  • ASHRAE/IES Standard 202, Commissioning Process for Buildings and Systems. It sets the minimum acceptable commissioning process: what has to be done and documented, written so code officials and owners can require it.
  • ASHRAE Guideline 0, The Commissioning Process (2019 edition). It describes the same process in more depth and recommends practices beyond the Standard 202 minimum, and it aligns its terms with 202.
  • LEED. In LEED v4 and v4.1 for new construction, Fundamental Commissioning and Verification is a prerequisite under Energy and Atmosphere. It covers mechanical, electrical, plumbing and renewable energy systems, requires the owner to engage a CxA by the end of design development, and asks for a CxA with documented commissioning experience on at least two building projects of similar scope. Enhanced Commissioning is an optional credit that adds work such as a post-occupancy review and, as an option, envelope commissioning.

Energy codes add their own requirements. The commercial provisions of the International Energy Conservation Code include a commissioning section (C408) that calls for functional testing and documentation of certain mechanical, service water heating and lighting control systems, with exceptions that depend on the edition your jurisdiction adopted. Your specifications, usually in Division 01 and the commissioning sections of Divisions 21 to 28, are what actually bind you. Read them at buyout.

The vocabulary you’ll see

  • OPR (owner’s project requirements): the owner’s written goals for how the building must perform and be operated, with measurable criteria. Everything is tested against it.
  • BOD (basis of design): the design team’s explanation of how the design meets the OPR: systems chosen, assumptions, design conditions.
  • Cx plan: the project’s commissioning roadmap: scope, team, schedule, documentation and the tests to be run.
  • Construction checklists (often called prefunctional checklists): installation and start-up checks each trade completes before functional testing.
  • TAB: testing, adjusting and balancing of air and water systems, done by a TAB contractor and verified by the CxA.
  • FPTs (functional performance tests): the CxA runs or witnesses each system through its sequences of operation, normal and failure modes, and records pass or fail.
  • Issues log: every deficiency found, who owns it and how it was resolved. Closing it is the gate.
  • Systems manual and Cx report: the record of what was tested and how the systems should be run.
Who leads commissioning work in each project phaseFive phases from left to right: pre-design, design, construction, acceptance and warranty. The owner writes the owner’s project requirements in pre-design and receives training and the systems manual at acceptance. The commissioning authority is engaged by design, reviews the design, writes and updates the Cx plan, verifies construction checklists, runs functional tests and leads the warranty-year review. The design team writes the basis of design and the Cx specifications and answers issues. The GC and trades do submittals, construction checklists, start-up and test and balance during construction, support functional tests and fix issues at acceptance, and return for warranty fixes and seasonal tests.PRE-DESIGNDESIGNCONSTRUCTIONACCEPTANCEWARRANTYOwnerwrites OPRtrainingCxAdesign review · Cx plan · checklists · FPTsreviewDesign teamBOD · specssubmittals · answers issuesGC + tradesstart-up · TABfix issuesseasonal
Who leads in each phase. The GC’s work is concentrated in construction and acceptance, which is why Cx belongs on the schedule.

Who does what

Owner. Writes or approves the OPR, hires the CxA (ideally independent of the design team and the contractor), makes decisions on issues the CxA raises, and sends its operators to training. On LEED projects the owner is the one who must engage the CxA by the end of design development.

Commissioning authority. Plans and leads the process: reviews the OPR and BOD, reviews the design for commissionability, writes the Cx specifications or the requirements that go into them, keeps the Cx plan current, reviews submittals for Cx-related items, verifies construction checklists, runs or witnesses functional tests, keeps the issues log and writes the final report. The CxA verifies; it doesn’t do the trades’ work or direct the means and methods.

Design team. Writes the BOD, puts commissioning requirements into the construction documents, answers design issues the CxA finds, and updates the BOD when the design changes.

General contractor. Owns the schedule and the coordination. In practice that means: commissioning activities on the CPM schedule with real durations; making sure the commissioning specification sections are in every relevant subcontract at buyout; collecting construction checklists and start-up reports; getting TAB finished before functional tests; having each trade’s technicians on site for their tests; and driving the issues log to zero the same way you drive the punch list.

Subcontractors and suppliers. Mechanical, electrical, plumbing, fire protection, controls, TAB and equipment manufacturers complete their checklists, perform start-up, fix issues and attend tests. Controls is usually the critical one: most functional test failures trace back to sequences, points or calibration.

When it happens

Phase Cx work GC’s part
Pre-design OPR written Usually none
Design CxA engaged; BOD written; design review; Cx specs; Cx plan drafted Precon: price and schedule the Cx scope
Construction Submittal review; construction checklists; start-up; TAB Buyout with Cx sections; collect checklists; book start-ups
Acceptance Functional tests; issues log; training; systems manual; Cx report Crews at tests; close issues; deliver O&M and training
Warranty year Seasonal and deferred tests; review before warranty ends (enhanced Cx) Return for deferred tests and warranty fixes

Where it goes wrong for the GC

  1. Cx isn’t on the schedule. Functional tests need finished, powered, controlled systems and a completed TAB report. If those are a single “commissioning” bar in the last two weeks, the schedule is wrong.
  2. The subcontracts don’t carry it. If the controls or TAB subcontract doesn’t include checklist, test attendance and retest obligations, you pay for every retest yourself.
  3. Start-up is confused with functional testing. Start-up proves the equipment runs. Functional testing proves the system does what the sequences say in every mode. Both are needed, in that order.
  4. The issues log becomes a second punch list nobody owns. Give it one owner on the GC side and review it in the same weekly meeting as punch.
  5. Seasonal tests are forgotten. Heating can’t be tested in July. Deferred tests should be listed at substantial completion with dates, or they’ll still be open at the warranty walk.

How Cx fits into closeout

On many jobs, commissioning sits on the path to occupancy. Fire alarm and sprinkler acceptance tests are separate code inspections, but they compete for the same weeks and the same trades, and a building department won’t issue a temporary certificate of occupancy until life safety systems pass. The closeout to occupancy guide shows where commissioning sits between substantial completion, the TCO and CO, and final payment, and the closeout and TCO checklist has a commissioning section you can hand to your MEP subs. For definitions, see commissioning, O&M manuals and substantial completion.

os.construction has no commissioning module today. Teams track Cx issues as items in the punch list with location, photos, assignees and a review-and-close step, keep test reports and the systems manual in Documents, and put functional tests and seasonal retests on the schedule as activities. For the mechanical subcontractor’s view, where startup, test and balance and closeout documents decide when retainage is released, see mechanical contractor software.

Sources

General information. Commissioning scope is set by your contract documents, the project’s certification targets and the codes your jurisdiction adopted.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file