Esc

↑↓ move↵ openIndex · Pagefind

Submittal vs RFI: which one to send, and why it matters

A submittal shows the design team what you plan to furnish and install; an RFI asks them what the documents mean. Here is how the two differ, when to use each, how they connect, a worked example and the mistakes that cost time and money.

Charley Forey5 min readProject managementRFIsField
On this page
  1. Side by side
  2. When to send a submittal
  3. When to send an RFI
  4. How they connect
  5. Who owns each one on the GC side
  6. A worked example
  7. Common mistakes
  8. Tools
  9. FAQ

A submittal shows the architect or engineer what the contractor intends to furnish and install, such as shop drawings, product data or samples, so they can check it against the design. An RFI (request for information) asks the design team what the drawings or specifications mean when they are unclear, incomplete or in conflict. A submittal says “here is what we will build”; an RFI asks “what do you want us to build?” Neither one changes the contract price or time by itself.

Both go to the same people, both carry a ball in court and a due date, and both sit in logs the PM reviews every week, so they get mixed up. Sending the wrong one costs days, because the reviewer returns it, and sometimes costs money, because an answer that changes scope never gets priced.

Side by side

Submittal RFI
Purpose Show how the work will meet the documents Clarify what the documents require
Direction Contractor proposes, designer reviews Contractor asks, designer answers
Required by The specifications, item by item Whatever question comes up
Usually prepared by Sub or supplier, reviewed and stamped by the GC Field staff or a sub, reviewed and sent by the GC
Typical content Shop drawings, product data, samples, test reports, calcs Question, drawing and spec references, photos, a proposed answer
Typical response An action code: approved, approved as noted, revise and resubmit, rejected A written answer, sketch or supplemental instruction
Known in advance Yes, listed on the submittal register No
Changes the contract No, by itself No, by itself
Can lead to Fabrication and ordering A change event if the answer changes scope or time
Submittal and RFI flow in opposite directionsThe contractor and the design team are shown as two boxes. An RFI travels from the contractor to the design team as a question and returns as an answer. A submittal travels from the contractor to the design team as a proposal and returns as an action code. Either answer can open a change event if scope, cost or time changes.CONTRACTORGC AND SUBSDESIGN TEAMARCHITECT, ENG.RFI: WHAT DO YOU WANT?ANSWERSUBMITTAL: HERE IS OUR PLANACTION CODEIF SCOPE, COST OR TIME CHANGES: OPEN A CHANGE EVENT
Same parties, opposite questions. Neither path changes the contract until a change order does.

When to send a submittal

Send a submittal when the specifications ask for one. The submittal procedures section, usually Section 01 33 00 in MasterFormat-organized specs, sets the general rules, and each technical section lists the shop drawings, product data, samples and other items it needs. Build the register from those sections at the start of the job, schedule each item backward from its install date, and send it after the GC has reviewed it for field dimensions, coordination and completeness.

A submittal is the right vehicle when you are proposing how you will meet the documents: the anchor layout for a curtain wall, the specific pump model, the color of the brick. If something in it deviates from the documents, call that deviation out in writing. Reviewers are not expected to find it for you, and under AIA-based general conditions an approval generally doesn’t cover a deviation you didn’t identify.

When to send an RFI

Send an RFI when you can’t tell what the documents require: two sheets disagree, a dimension is missing, a detail doesn’t fit the field condition, or a spec calls for a product that has been discontinued. A good RFI asks one question, references the sheet and spec section, includes a photo or sketch, proposes an answer and says when you need it. How to write an RFI covers the format in detail.

Before sending, check that the answer isn’t already in the documents. RFIs that are answered with “see sheet A-501” waste the reviewer’s time and erode the credibility of the ones that matter.

How they connect

The two often travel together. An RFI answer can change what a submittal has to show, and a submittal review can expose a conflict that needs an RFI. When that happens, reference one in the other so the record shows the chain, and if the answer changes scope or time, open a change event the same day. The RFI to change order explainer follows that path to billing.

Who owns each one on the GC side

On most jobs a project engineer or assistant PM runs both logs, but the ownership is different. Submittals belong to the trade that will furnish the work: the sub prepares the package, and the GC’s job is to review it, push it through on time and make sure the approved version reaches the field. RFIs belong to whoever found the problem, usually the superintendent or a foreman, and the GC’s job is to make the question clear, check it isn’t already answered, and distribute the answer to every trade it affects.

That difference shows up in the logs. A late submittal is usually a sub follow-up problem. A late RFI answer is usually a design team follow-up problem, and a pattern of them is worth raising at the OAC meeting with the dates in hand.

A worked example

Illustrative: the electrical sub prepares the lighting fixture submittal and finds that the fixture schedule calls for a recessed fixture in a corridor where the reflected ceiling plan shows an exposed structure with no ceiling.

The wrong move is to submit a surface-mounted fixture with no explanation and hope the reviewer catches it. The right sequence:

  1. RFI first. “Sheet E-201 schedules type F3 recessed at corridor 140. Sheet A-401 shows open structure at corridor 140. Please confirm the fixture type. Proposed: pendant version of F3 at 10’-0” AFF. Answer needed by June 12 to hold the fixture release.” The architect answers: use the pendant version.
  2. Submittal next. The fixture submittal includes the pendant version for corridor 140 and references the RFI number.
  3. Change event if needed. The pendant fixture costs more than the recessed one, plus stems and labor. The PM logs a change event tied to the RFI so the cost gets priced, rather than buried in the sub’s next invoice.

Common mistakes

  • Using an RFI to ask for a substitution. Most specs set out a separate substitution procedure with its own deadline. Follow it.
  • Hiding a deviation in a submittal. If it isn’t called out, approval usually doesn’t cover it.
  • Treating an RFI answer as a change order. It isn’t one. Price the change and get it approved.
  • Passing sub submittals through unreviewed. The GC’s review stamp means something under most contracts.
  • Late submittals on long-lead items. Fabrication can’t start until the action code allows it.
  • No cross-references. When the RFI, submittal and change event don’t point to each other, nobody can reconstruct the story at closeout.

Tools

The RFI checklist covers what every RFI should include, the RFI response time calculator measures turnaround, and how to track submittals and the submittals without the chase explainer cover the register.

In os.construction, RFIs carry ball in court, due dates and Related Items that link to submittals, drawings and change events, and submittals route through an ordered approval workflow with ball in court on each step. A drawing revision can link the RFIs raised against it, and an approved submittal can be prepared into a purchase request, so each log feeds the next step instead of a retyped list.

FAQ

What is the difference between a submittal and an RFI?

A submittal is a package the contractor sends to show what it intends to furnish and install, such as shop drawings, product data or samples, so the design team can review it against the design intent. An RFI is a question the contractor sends when the drawings or specifications are unclear, incomplete or in conflict. A submittal says 'here is what we will do'; an RFI asks 'what do you want?'

Can an RFI be used to request a substitution?

Usually not. Most specifications set out a separate substitution request procedure with its own deadlines and required information. Asking for a different product through an RFI tends to get it returned, and an informal yes may not count as an approved substitution.

Does an approved submittal change the contract?

Generally no. Under AIA-based general conditions, submittal approval doesn't authorize a change to the contract documents unless the contractor specifically called out the deviation in writing and the architect specifically approved it, and even then a cost or time change still needs a change order. Other contract forms take similar approaches.

Who prepares submittals and RFIs?

Submittals are usually prepared by the subcontractor or supplier who will furnish the work, reviewed and stamped by the general contractor, and sent to the architect or engineer. RFIs can start with anyone on the build side, but the general contractor normally reviews, numbers and sends them so the design team gets one official stream of questions.

Are submittals and RFIs required by the contract?

Submittals are required item by item by the specifications, usually listed in the submittal procedures section and in each technical section. RFIs are not scheduled in advance; they are raised as questions come up, though the contract often sets a procedure and a response time for them.

Share this article

Written by

Charley Forey

Founder of os.construction. We're building the operating system for construction. Project Financials follows job money, and company Accounting covers the books and controls. AI agents remain planned. We write about how money and data actually move on a job, and we build in public.

Apply to the founding program →Start a free trial →
Open file